The decision came after an hour and a half of contentious debate inside a City Commission chambers packed with staff and spectators.
Commissioners voted to invalidate a controversial provision requiring a 4-1 super-majority to fire Jumonville, a clause no previous city manager had held, and terminated her immediately. Former Mayor Dailey had previously voted in favor of Jumonville when she was hired in June alongside Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox and Curtis Richardson.
Commissioner Jack Porter, who seconded the motion, and new City Commissioner P.J. Perez joined Matlow to form the new progressive majority backing the termination. City Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox and Curtis Richardson voted no.
The ouster follows months of political realignment and behind-the-scenes friction. Jumonville, a 27-year city employee, was appointed city manager in June by a previous commission majority. Matlow argued that trust had never been established, pointing to discussions before her hiring regarding a one-year probationary period that she rejected.
“That did not build trust with me,” Matlow said, according to the Tallahassee Democrat. “And I think it is imperative. We can’t move forward as a city with a city manager that doesn’t have a relationship with the mayor that’s based on a trust and mutual respect.”
Matlow added:

“And we just don’t have that right now.”
Opposing commissioners pushed back sharply against the timing and tone of the move. Williams-Cox criticized the decision while city employees face uncertainty during the holiday season, and suggested that Matlow bore responsibility for the roots of the problem and a toxic relationship with city leaders.
“I understand you don’t want to discuss that today, but the facts are the facts,” she said.
Williams-Cox also said: “It’s Thanksgiving and Christmas season,” Williams-Cox said, as reported by the Tallahassee Democrat. “We have employees who are worried about whether they’re going to be able to continue to have a livelihood through the end of the year. It’s cruel and unusual punishment for people who’ve dedicated their lives to the city of Tallahassee.”
Porter said that the decision was not personal and that job applicants understood the risks involved with an upcoming election cycle.
Following the termination, Matlow moved to appoint Deputy City Attorney Lou Norvell as interim city manager. City Attorney Amy Toman noted during the proceedings that Jumonville has retained counsel, warning commissioners that the abrupt dismissal exposes the city to potential litigation.
“As I’ve said, it does expose the city to potential litigation,” Toman said.
After the vote, a stunned Richardson asked Toman to “tell us what’s next.”