Tennessee will pay $70,000 to a former pop singer after troopers arrested her for drunk driving while she was sober, the state Board of Claims approved this week.
Stefanie Fair, 53, a former member of the 1990s group Wild Orchid, was pulled over in Nashville last June for failing to move over during a traffic stop. Trooper Keith Velez claimed he smelled a “very distinct odor of alcohol” and arrested her after a field sobriety test, body-camera footage obtained by WSMV4 shows. Blood work later returned clean — no alcohol, no drugs — and the charge was dismissed.
“If this could happen to me completely sober … it was just like, very scary,” Fair told WSMV4.
The settlement makes Fair the second sober driver to win a payout from the Tennessee Highway Patrol in recent months. Thomas Manis received $75,000 after his arrest in Monroe County in December 2023.
Fair’s attorney, Ben Raybin, said the state settled because it recognized the cases would not survive a jury trial.

“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them.”
Raybin told WSMV4. He added that Tennessee offers no administrative path for sober drivers to recover legal costs after a DUI charge is dropped — a lawsuit is the only option.
The WSMV4 Investigates unit, which first reported Fair’s arrest in its “Sobering Problem” series, has identified at least nine sober drivers arrested by a single trooper, James Zahn. Among them are former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant and NASA employee Labreesha Batey, both of whom have filed suit. A Thompson Station man sued this year alleging he was the ninth.
The problem extends beyond state troopers. Court records show the Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and the La Vergne Police Department have also settled lawsuits with sober drivers arrested for DUI.
Wild Orchid formed in 1990 as NRG, signed with RCA Records in 1994, and released a self-titled debut album in 1997 that sold nearly a million units worldwide. The trio also hosted the Fox Family Channel show Great Pretenders from 1998 to 2002 and toured as an opening act for NSYNC and 98 Degrees.
Fair’s payout is expected within weeks, a spokesman for the attorney general’s office told WSMV4.