Top 25 Columbus Home Sales for October 2026: New Albany Leads Luxury Market

Columbus Monthly published its October 2026 luxury market snapshot Wednesday, revealing a $2.4 million deal in New Albany that paced the region’s top 25 closed sales.

The list, compiled from county auditor records across Franklin, Delaware, Licking and Union counties, shows New Albany claimed 11 of the 25 highest-priced transactions for the month. Upper Arlington and Westerville each landed three spots, while Dublin, Grandview Heights, Blacklick and Columbus proper split the remainder.

New Albany dominates the upper tier

Eleven closings in New Albany ranged from $977,000 to $2.4 million. The top three — Brandon Road at $2.4 million, Lambton Park Road at $2.31 million and Oxford Loop North at $2.25 million — all closed above the $2.25 million threshold. Sandy Raines of The Raines Group appeared on four New Albany transactions, both listing and buying sides, including a dual-role deal at 7330 Stone Gate Drive for $1.1 million.

Westerville followed with three sales between $1.1 million and $1.14 million. Upper Arlington matched that count, anchored by a $1.38 million York Road property and two $1.3 million deals on Donna Drive and Burbank Drive. Dublin posted two sales: Wolf Ridge Drive at $1.3 million and Emmet Row Lane at $999,900.

Top 25 Columbus Home Sales for October 2026: New Albany Leads Luxury Market
Photo: aol.com

Intra-office deals signal tight inventory

Seven of the 25 transactions closed with the same agent or firm representing both buyer and seller. Coldwell Banker Realty handled both sides on Ravine Drive in Westerville ($1.13 million) and Preston Road in Columbus ($1.69 million). New Albany Realty did the same on Calverton Square ($1.85 million) and Goodheart Court ($1.14 million). The Raines Group, Cutler Real Estate and Red 1 Realty each recorded one dual-sided closing.

“When you see this many in-house deals at the top end, it tells you buyers are moving fast and listing agents are holding the cards,” said Brad Winter of Engel & Völkers, who listed the Greensward Road sale at $1.21 million. He told Columbus Monthly the pace leaves little room for outside buyer’s agents to insert themselves.

Price floor holds at $977,000

The 25th-ranked sale — 4630 Burbank Drive in Upper Arlington — closed at $977,000, setting the entry threshold for the month’s elite tier. The median of the 25 sales sits near $1.3 million, with eight properties clustering between $1.1 million and $1.38 million.

Address Community Sale Price
7708 Brandon Rd. New Albany $2.4M
7685 Lambton Park Rd. New Albany $2.31M
7100 Oxford Loop N. New Albany $2.25M
7859 Calverton Sq. New Albany $1.85M
7280 Waterston New Albany $1.8M
57 Preston Rd. Columbus $1.69M
7618 Alpath Rd. New Albany $1.6M
7247 Poppy Hills Ct. Blacklick $1.5M
1313 Lincoln Rd. Grandview Heights $1.42M
2615 York Rd. Upper Arlington $1.38M
318 Jackson St. Columbus $1.3M
2391 Donna Dr. Upper Arlington $1.3M
3264 Wolf Ridge Dr. Dublin $1.3M
6988 Greensward Rd. New Albany $1.21M
4611 Goodheart Ct. New Albany $1.14M
4528 Ravine Dr. Westerville $1.13M
7800 Straits Ln. New Albany $1.1M
7182 Hoover Reserve Ct. N. Westerville $1.1M
7330 Stone Gate Dr. New Albany $1.1M
6059 Victory Ln. Westerville $1.1M
5502 Via Alvito Dr. Westerville $1.07M
7164 Emmet Row Ln. Dublin $999,900
7455 Farmington Close New Albany $991,000
7320 Stone Gate Dr. New Albany $977,000
4630 Burbank Dr. Upper Arlington $977,000

Data sourced from Franklin, Delaware, Licking and Union county auditor offices for October 1–31, 2026. Realtor information via Redfin.

Agent details behind the top deals

The $2.4 million Brandon Road sale was listed by and bought with Ron Guzzo of Re/Max Premier Choice. The $2.31 million Lambton Park Road property was listed by Amy Conley of Cutler Real Estate and bought with Matt Ackermann of Re/Max Consultant Group. The $2.25 million Oxford Loop North home was listed by Mark Neff of New Albany Realty, LTD and bought with Megan Hardgrove of The Brokerage House.

The $1.85 million Calverton Square deal was listed by and bought with Alan Hinson of New Albany Realty, LTD. The $1.69 million Preston Road sale was listed by and bought with Mike Carruthers of Coldwell Banker Realty. The $1.38 million York Road property was listed by Lauren Pearson of Re/Max Consultant Group.

The $1.3 million Jackson Street sale was listed by Jeffery Ruff of Cutler Real Estate and bought with Michael McCoy of Cutler Real Estate. The $1.3 million Donna Drive home was listed by Cece Miller of NextHome Experience and bought with Susie Pattison of Cutler Real Estate. The $1.3 million Wolf Ridge Drive property was listed by Susan Wainfor of Coldwell Banker Realty and bought with George Pattison of Cutler Real Estate.

The $1.14 million Goodheart Court deal was listed by and bought with Rob Riddle of New Albany Realty, LTD. The $1.1 million Straits Lane sale was listed by Sandy Raines of The Raines Group and bought with Lauren Davie of Engel & Völkers Real Estate Advisors. The $1.1 million Victory Lane property was listed by Robb Harpster of Century 21 Excellence Realty and bought with Angela Tampone of 24 Karat Real Estate. The $999,900 Emmet Row Lane home was listed by Sam Cooper of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services and bought with Abigail Swihart Valentine of Red 1 Realty.

The $991,000 Farmington Close sale was listed by Katie Davis Spence of The Brokerage House and bought with Sandy Raines of The Raines Group. The $977,000 Stone Gate Drive property was listed by Ron Guzzo of RE/MAX Premier Choice and bought with Sandy Raines of The Raines Group. The $977,000 Burbank Drive sale was listed by Philip Crawford of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services and bought with Cece Miller of NextHome Experience.

The December issue of Columbus Monthly hits newsstands next week.