Treasurer, Deputy Mayor Tell Brodie to Stop Calling City ‘Broke

Albany Treasurer Darius Shahinfar and Deputy Mayor Chris Ellis summoned Common Councilmember Deirdre Brodie to a private Zoom meeting Friday and told her to stop describing the city as “broke,” even as officials arranged a $10 million loan to cover payroll through year‑end, Times Union reported.

The meeting, also attended by Common Council President Kelly Kimbrough and Council President Pro Tempore Ginnie Farrell, came after Brodie posted an Instagram video reacting to news of the borrowing. “Why does Wall Street get to know how to profit off of us before we’re telling people on Lark Street how bad the situation is?” Brodie said in the video as she walked her 6th Ward neighborhood.

During the Zoom call, Shahinfar alleged that Brodie’s video and resulting media coverage — not the loan itself — had worried S&P Global and could cause the agency to downgrade the city’s credit rating again. A Times Union reporter obtained an AI‑generated transcript of the meeting. “Everybody knows our financial situation; everybody knows this,” Shahinfar said, implying that councilmembers need not make videos about it.

Treasurer, Deputy Mayor Tell Brodie to Stop Calling City 'Broke
Photo: newslocker.com

Brodie compared the session to being called into the principal’s office and, in a subsequent Instagram video, said: “If the thinking was to tell us to go sit quietly in the corner, I’m not here for that.” In a later phone conversation she added: “If I don’t use this platform, I don’t know why I have this job.”

Elected to the council last year by a three‑vote margin, Brodie said she ran to address housing affordability and downtown revitalization but found the city’s fiscal crisis consuming her role. “It’s insulting to the people of Albany,” she told the Times Union. “We all got voted on. We all were chosen. There’s no reason we should be hiding now.”

Albany, the capital of New York since 1797, is the oldest surviving settlement from the original Thirteen Colonies north of Virginia and the longest continuously chartered city in the United States, receiving its charter in 1686. The city sits on the west bank of the Hudson River, roughly ten miles south of where it meets the Mohawk River, and anchors the Capital District, a metropolitan area with an estimated 1.3 million residents.

Shahinfar later said the meeting had been misinterpreted. “All of this is a distraction from the job they need to do,” he said.