“If I were you, I would have killed her,” Christian Evans reportedly told Bryanna Dutcher over the phone hours before her mother was shot dead, Delaware Gazette reported Thursday.
A Delaware County grand jury returned a new indictment Thursday against Dajameous Payne, 21; Christian Evans, 20; and Bryanna Dutcher, 18, expanding the charges in the August killing of Tamela D. Dutcher, 55, on Bean Oller Road.
The trio now faces aggravated murder, murder, attempted murder, felonious assault, and tampering with evidence, all but the last carrying firearm specifications that add a mandatory three years to any prison sentence. Bryanna Dutcher also picked up an obstructing justice count.
The case has moved fast since the early-morning shooting on Aug. 14. Deputies arrested all three that afternoon. An August indictment charged them with aggravated murder, but the trial date slipped from October to Jan. 12, 2027. Thursday’s superseding indictment replaces the earlier one and adds the attempted murder count tied to a second shot fired at the victim’s husband.
“Text messages were recovered from Bryanna Dutcher’s phone that appear to be planning the crime in advance,” Assistant Prosecutor Mark Sleeper said at an August hearing, noting she had tried to delete them. Law enforcement retrieved the messages anyway.
The probable-cause affidavit paints a chaotic scene. Tamela Dutcher’s husband was in the basement when he heard the first shot. He found his wife shot in the face and called 911 while bending over her; a second round missed him and struck the wall. She died at a hospital hours later.
Bryanna Dutcher initially told detectives she was cleaning a utility room and saw no one enter. Under further questioning, she admitted she had argued with her mother about cleaning and vented to Evans, her secret boyfriend. Evans and Payne arrived in Evans’ Camaro the evening of Aug. 13. About 10 to 15 minutes after she stayed behind, she heard gunfire.
Traffic cameras caught the Camaro at Columbus Pike and East Powell Road at 12:44 a.m. Aug. 14. The pair drove to West Virginia before returning to Ohio, where deputies spotted Evans tossing a garbage bag into a dumpster at the apartment he shared with Payne.
Inside the bag: a gun holster and two pairs of black pants in different sizes. Evans was not formally questioned at the scene but told officers he was “sorry for what he did.”
Bryanna Dutcher also told investigators that Payne had threatened to kidnap her family months earlier and that she was afraid of him.
All three remain held in the Delaware County Jail. New arraignment dates on the expanded charges have not been set.