Two Incumbents Unseated in Charleston County School Board Election

Two Incumbents Unseated in Charleston County School Board Election

by

Joy Brown beat incumbent Leah Whatley by just 47 votes in District 7, a margin so thin it could have swung on a single precinct’s late-arriving ballots, and by the time all the votes were counted late Tuesday night, the Charleston County School Board had taken on a noticeably different shape than the one voters left behind in 2024.

Five seats were on the ballot in the Nov. 3 election, and four of the five sitting board members ran for re-election. When the dust settled, two of those incumbents — Carlotte Bailey in District 5 and Whatley in District 7 — had been unseated, according to WCIV. Yahoo News characterized both as conservative-leaning and described the result as the board’s makeup tilting away from its conservative center.

Grybowski Survives a Three-Way Fight in Mount Pleasant

In District 1, which covers the East Cooper and Mount Pleasant areas, incumbent Keith Grybowski held on to his seat with 41 percent of the vote, fending off Char Fitzwater, a former regional insurance CFO and grandmother to two CCSD students, and Mark Little, a father of three Charleston County public school graduates who works in finance. All precincts reported by around 11:20 p.m., WCIV reported.

Tisdale’s 61 Percent Upsets Bailey in North Charleston

The bigger shakeup came in District 5, which includes portions of North Charleston. There, Libby Tisdale — a James Island High School graduate, mother of three CCSD graduates and a substitute teacher — unseated incumbent Carlotte Bailey with 61 percent of the vote.

Bailey’s loss was one of only two incumbent defeats on the night, but it carried symbolic weight: Yahoo News described Bailey as conservative-leaning, and her ouster, combined with Whatley’s, suggests voters in those districts were looking for a change in direction.

Whatley Falls Short by 47 Votes in West Ashley

In District 7, which comprises the West Ashley area, Joy Brown — a former vice chair of the CCSD District 10 Constituent School Board — unseated Whatley with 34 percent of the vote, with Whatley coming up just 47 votes short, according to WCIV. Yahoo confirmed the 47-vote margin and the district’s West Ashley boundaries.

Open Seat in District 3 Goes to Nemitz

District 3, which includes parts of downtown and North Charleston, was an open seat after incumbent Pamela McKinney announced she would not seek re-election because she is moving outside the district’s boundaries. Four candidates battled for the spot, and Bethany Nemitz secured it with 36 percent of the vote, ahead of Stuart Day, Joseph Bennett and Tressa Pankovits.

Tempel Holds Firm in District 9

Not every incumbent fell. In District 9 — which spans portions of James Island, Folly Beach, the Kiawah/Seabrook Islands and Johns Island — incumbent Carol Tempel held on to her seat with 59 percent of the vote against challenger Karen Lurhs, with all precincts reporting.

Why This Board Matters Right Now

As WCIV noted, the newly elected members will oversee local schools, approve the district’s budget and school curricula, evaluate the superintendent, and monitor students’ academic progress. That means the two new faces — Tisdale and Brown — will have a direct hand in spending decisions and academic direction for thousands of Charleston County families.

The board they join has spent recent years embroiled in controversy, with two pronounced factions clashing over leadership decisions and committee composition, raising concerns among residents and state and local leaders, Yahoo reported. Although disagreements remain, Yahoo noted, the conflicts appear to have subsided and the board seems to have reached some equilibrium since the 2024 election.

What happens next is built into the job itself: the newly elected board members will approve the district’s budget and curricula, evaluate the superintendent and monitor academic progress across Mount Pleasant, North Charleston, West Ashley and the islands.

Worth a look

Read next