Dane County DA Clears Madison Officer in Fatal Shooting of Corey Ruiz

Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne cleared a Madison police officer of criminal wrongdoing on Thursday in the July shooting death of Corey Ruiz, a decision that reignited protests and left the victim’s family calling the outcome an execution.

Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson shot Ruiz, 38, twice at close range on July 22 after a struggle at a busy intersection near the city’s downtown. Ozanne concluded the officer’s use of deadly force was reasonable because Ruiz resisted arrest, produced a knife and was not incapacitated by multiple Taser deployments, The Center Square reported.

Madison police officer who fatally shot Corey Ruiz over the summer will not face charges — CBS 58

“I conclude it was reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers while officers attempted to take him into custody,” Ozanne wrote in his decision.

Ben Crump, the Ruiz family’s attorney, rejected that finding at a news conference Thursday. “That officer was not stabbed,” Crump told a cheering crowd. “There was nothing in the video that he showed us that justified the use of this excessive deadly force.”

The confrontation and the video

Police responded that afternoon to reports of a man looking into parked cars and possibly attempting a burglary, according to the New York Times. Officers said Ruiz fled on a bicycle before pulling a knife during a physical struggle. Tasers failed to stop him, and Baitinger-Peterson — who police said was injured by the knife — fired the fatal shots.

Prosecutors showed the family dash-camera footage from a police cruiser on Thursday. Crump said the video did not show Ruiz swinging the knife at officers, contradicting the police narrative. “We were going to have some revelation, that we were going to see some video from an angle of him swinging the knife at officers. We saw none of that,” Crump said. No body-camera footage captured the shooting.

A familiar pattern for Madison

The shooting occurred near the same area where a Madison officer killed Anthony Robinson Jr., a 19-year-old Black man, in 2015. Ozanne also declined to file charges in that case, ruling the force justified. The Ruiz decision renewed longstanding concerns about how Black residents are treated by police in Wisconsin’s capital city.

Ruiz was Black. Baitinger-Peterson, hired in 2015, had no prior history of deadly force, the New York Times reported. After the July shooting, he and the other officers involved were placed on administrative leave.

Ruiz-Crump-Presser-05-20260724-269178.JPGWIS0004089150.JPG
Photo: wjfw.com

City braces for unrest

Madison officials ordered police to work 12-hour shifts and placed the department’s drone team and SWAT unit on alert Thursday. The department also set up dedicated arrest processing sites in anticipation of a “flood of arrests” over the coming days, The Center Square reported.

“Justice for Corey Ruiz,” family members and supporters chanted Thursday, though Crump did not define what specific outcome they would accept beyond criminal charges.

Madison police address fatal shooting of Corey Ruiz — FOX 32 Chicago

Competing accounts of the evidence

The prosecutor’s report stated Ruiz injured the officer who shot him. Crump flatly disputed that claim Thursday, telling the crowd the officer was not stabbed. The dash-cam video shown to the family has not been released publicly; prosecutors indicated it would be made available.

Public records show Ruiz had prior convictions for theft and resisting or obstructing an officer. Family members described him as a caring father.