Minneapolis City Council voted 8-5 last Thursday to reject interim Police Chief Bill Peterson’s nomination for the permanent role, leaving Mayor Jacob Frey to decide whether to veto the decision and restart a search that has already cost taxpayers $68,000.
The rejection caps a monthslong national search that drew roughly 20 applicants before every external candidate dropped out, leaving four department veterans as finalists. Peterson, a 31-year veteran who has led the department since former Chief Brian O’Hara resigned in May, now remains in the interim post while the political standoff plays out.
The vote split the council along lines that have defined Minneapolis politics for years. Council President Elliott Payne and members Robin Wonsley, Aisha Chughtai, Aurin Chowdhury, Soren Stevenson, Jason Chavez and Pearll Warren voted no; LaTrisha Vetaw joined them despite her past alliance with Frey. Supporting Peterson were Michael Rainville, Jamal Osman, Linea Palmisano, Elizabeth Shaffer and Jamison Whiting.
Warren wrote on Facebook after the vote that her position is not personal; it is principled, citing two open misconduct complaints against Peterson.
Vetaw said she opposed Peterson because she preferred another finalist, Deputy Chief Charlie Adams, a North Side native she credited with helping curb violence in the Fourth Precinct. Payne told CBS News he was surprised an internal candidate was brought forward at all, saying he wanted a nominee willing to show “some humility about the history of this department.”
Frey vetoed the council’s rejection late Thursday, a move that keeps Peterson’s nomination alive but requires nine votes to override — one more than the eight who opposed him.
“To a certain extent, a decision like that could put it into no man’s land where the decision would remain with the council because they likely don’t have the votes to override the mayoral veto, but I don’t yet have the votes to get a majority,” Frey told KSTP.

City officials confirmed the search cost $68,000 but have not estimated the price of starting over, KSTP reported. Former Council President Andrea Jenkins, who served on a community interview panel, warned that a restart would be risky: “There’s not a lot of people who are stepping forward to say, ‘I want to lead the Minneapolis Police Department.’”
Community Leaders Criticize the Search Process
Rev. Ian Bethel of the Unity Community Mediation Team wrote to Frey this week saying the mayor “hurt your reputation for community engagement with our most justice-impacted communities” by appearing to move a favored candidate late in the process and including only a few residents in final interviews. Bethel told CBS News residents “told their council members what they wanted, and Peterson was not it.”
We refused to rubber-stamp the status quo that has come at a devastating cost to our BIPOC residents—and to working-class residents of all backgrounds who are being priced out of their homes & neighborhoods due to MPD’s chronic overspending.
At the public hearing before the vote, 49 people testified, mostly in Peterson’s favor, and he spent about three hours answering questions, the Minnesota Star Tribune reported. Dozens of fellow police chiefs and metro law enforcement leaders gathered at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension headquarters Monday to praise Peterson’s leadership, giving him a standing ovation. “Everybody knows him and respects him,” Ramsey County Undersheriff Mike Martin said.
The Minneapolis City Council, a 13-member body where each member represents a single ward, has been the legislative branch since a 1951 charter amendment set its current size.
A 2021 voter-approved amendment then shifted the city to a strong-mayor system, stripping the council of its former executive powers and leaving it with purely legislative duties. This change frames the current standoff, where Mayor Jacob Frey holds the veto pen and the council must now decide whether its nine-vote override threshold is reachable.
Frey Faces Choices for Police Chief Nomination
Frey has not said whether he will nominate another finalist — Adams, Assistant Chief Mark Klukow, or Deputy Chief Jon Kingsbury — if Peterson’s path remains blocked. The chief’s term runs through January 2030 regardless of who fills it. For now, Peterson stays in charge, and the council that rejected him must decide whether to sustain its veto override or accept a candidate most of its members have already voted down.
More on Minneapolis City Council
The Minneapolis City Council has rejected Mayor Jacob Frey's pick for police chief, voting 8-5 against confirming interim Chief Bill Peterson. Peterson, a 31-year MPD veteran, faced tough questions from council members about police accountability, department culture and his… pic.twitter.com/qUgNDfkKyh