Utah lawmakers voted 11 to 2 on Wednesday to advance a bill that would repeal the state’s preliminary municipality program, dissolving the developer-led governments created under a 2024 law and returning land-use authority to county commissions.
“A repeal is going to happen,” said Sen. Calvin Musselman, a Republican who represents Davis and Weber counties, during the interim political subdivisions committee hearing. “Whether or not we come up with some sort of mechanism outside of that, I don’t know.”
The legislation, sponsored by Rep. Tiara Auxier, marks her third attempt to dismantle the statute since winning a special election to the House District 4 seat in 2025. If passed during the 2027 General Session, the bill would void Senate Bill 258, prohibit future applications, and dissolve any preliminary municipalities already certified by the Lieutenant Governor’s Office.
“You cannot fix the fundamental problem with this law by simply adding more requirements around the edges,” Auxier told the committee. She argued the statute violates the Utah Constitution’s prohibition on granting municipal powers to outside agencies or corporations.
The Wasatch Back flashpoint
The pilot program allows developers to incorporate a preliminary municipality, granting them “all the powers and duties” of a town — including zoning and planning authority — without election by residents. Proposals have surfaced in Summit and Wasatch counties, most notably the Lost Creek project in Browns Canyon sponsored by Ivory Development.
East Side residents have criticized the proposal for urbanizing one of the Wasatch Back’s historically rural communities. They have also expressed concerns about utilities and the ability for developers to obtain water rights in an area without existing infrastructure.
“I was also at a meeting where a feasibility study was presented and was quite flabbergasted by the issues that didn’t have to be in the feasibility study, like sewer and water,” said Celeste Johnson, former Midway mayor and incoming representative for House District 59. “The very best thing to do is repeal it, and then if we need to come up with something else, let’s do it right.”
“This isn’t about stopping people from developing their private property,” said Rep. Tiara Auxier, a Republican whose district covers parts of Rich, Morgan and Summit counties. “It’s about whether we should allow private developers to create their own governments, give themselves municipal zoning and planning authorities, and make decisions that affect entire communities without being accountable to the people who live there.”
Both the Summit County Council and Wasatch County Council have passed resolutions demanding repeal, arguing the law lets developers bypass local planning processes. “It isn’t about being pro-development or anti-development,” Auxier said. “This is about local control, representative governments and accountability to the people we serve.”
The property-rights counterargument
Ivory Development President Chris Gamvroulas was the lone speaker to defend the law. He described the tool as a necessary check against uncooperative county governments.
“The reason this tool exists is because of a weaponized county government against a property owner who had vested property rights,” Gamvroulas said. “This isn’t just a giveaway. No one in their right mind wants to use this tool. … Preliminary municipalities are the second-worst policy you could have. The only worse policy you could have is the status quo of weaponized county governments against property owners.”
Rep. Mike Kohler, the outgoing Republican representing House District 59, pushed back. He said he was often called to testify as a Wasatch County councilor because developers would follow the local process, fail to earn approval, and then accuse the county of weaponizing government.
“This is not that,” Kohler said. “We’re making decisions based on what the locals want.”
Dissolving municipalities preserves developer zoning rights
Auxier said dissolving the preliminary municipalities would not strip developers of zoning rights already obtained. She envisioned a path that retains those rights while removing the developer-appointed boards.
“It would restore the county’s land use authority going forward while protecting private rights that are actually valid and legally enforceable,” she said. “I don’t think we should preserve a government structure simply because we are concerned about what might happen to the private development rights associated with it.”
She also plans to add language making clear that any outstanding financial commitments at the time of dissolution remain the developer’s responsibility, not the county’s. “Restoring the government authority to elected county officials should not automatically transfer private developers’ financial commitments to county taxpayers,” Auxier said.
Sen. Calvin Musselman, a Republican who represents Davis and Weber counties, was born in Salt Lake City and raised in Monticello, Utah. He served in the United States Army during the Gulf War and has worked as an associate real estate broker at Golden Spike Realty in Ogden since 1999.
Musselman was elected to the Utah House of Representatives in 2018 and assumed office on January 1, 2019, before winning a seat in the Utah Senate in 2024.
Committee members questioned whether the move would invite lawsuits against the state, but largely agreed the pilot program is not working as intended. The bill now heads to the full Legislature for the 2027 General Session, which runs from Jan. 19 to March 5.