Washington Lawmaker Proposes Replacing B&O Tax With Corporate Income Tax

“Demolish” the business and occupation tax and replace it with a corporate income tax, Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen said in an interview last week, floating the idea days after voters upheld the state’s new tax on high-earner households.

Pedersen, a Seattle Democrat who helped write the 9.9% levy on household income above $1 million, said he has begun quiet talks with lawmakers, progressive groups and several major employers that have given “a qualified thumbs up on the project,” The Seattle Times reported. No legislation is expected before 2028.

The proposal would swap a nearly century-old tax on gross receipts for one on corporate profits, aligning Washington with more than 40 other states. The B&O tax currently generates about $7 billion a year, roughly 19% of state tax revenue, and falls heavily on low-margin, high-volume businesses such as grocery stores and restaurants regardless of profitability.

“Washington’s B&O tax is a punitive, economically inefficient tax that harms lower margin businesses and harms Washington consumers who are purchasing extensively from lower-margin businesses.”

Jared Walczak, a senior fellow at the Tax Foundation, told The Seattle Times. Replacing it with a corporate income tax, if done right, would be “a significant reform,” he added.

A 2020 Department of Revenue analysis estimated that replacing B&O revenue would have required a corporate income tax rate of 15.8% at the time, compared with an average top rate of 6.6% among states that impose one. Pedersen insists the swap would be revenue-neutral, but business groups worry the Democrat-controlled Legislature would use the change to raise more money, much as they did with the high-earners tax.

“There’s a lot of tax fatigue right now. We’re only a week past the vote on the last tax – it’s a little early to start talking about the next one.”

Brad Smith, vice chair and president at Microsoft and a veteran of state tax debates, told The Seattle Times.

The legal path remains uncertain. Income taxes have been effectively barred in Washington since a 1933 state Supreme Court ruling, and the recently enacted high-earners tax faces a lawsuit; proponents expect a ruling that overturns the 1933 precedent and opens the door to a corporate income tax.

Voters have rejected past income-tax proposals, including for a corporate income tax, and legislative bills have repeatedly languished. The failure of Initiative 645 this month, which sought to repeal the millionaires tax, signals to supporters that the electorate may now accept a narrowly targeted income tax.

Pedersen, who grew up in Puyallup and earned degrees from Yale and Yale Law School, first won a House seat in a 2006 primary decided by 229 votes.

He served as Lambda Legal’s lead attorney in Andersen v. King County, the state’s same-sex marriage case, before moving to the Senate in 2013 and becoming majority leader. He was the primary sponsor of Senate Bill 6346, which established the 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million that voters upheld this month.

Pedersen acknowledges that building an alternative requires extensive discussion on how a new tax would interact with existing state and local levies. Further consideration is expected in the coming years.