Idaho imprisons women at the highest rate in the nation, and a new watchdog report shows drug possession is the single biggest engine behind that growth.
The state’s independent Office of Performance Evaluations found that drug possession sentences accounted for 39% of Idaho’s prison population growth over the past decade — more than any other crime — according to the 88-page study released Wednesday and reported by the Idaho Capital Sun. The report was requested in March by a bipartisan group of lawmakers trying to understand why the state’s incarceration rate remains the seventh-highest in the country and the highest in the Mountain West, even as national imprisonment rates fell alongside declining crime.
“While women are less likely than men to be incarcerated for drug possession, they are much less likely to be incarcerated for other crimes,” the report says. “More than half of the growth of women in custody over the past two decades comes from women convicted of a single drug possession charge.”
“I don’t think the women in our state are the worst in the country. I really don’t. And what we’re seeing in the data is telling us that.”
Christopher Shank, the report’s lead analyst, said during the Joint Legislative Oversight Committee meeting on Wednesday.
The gender gap in the numbers
The disparity is stark. Twice as many women were imprisoned in Idaho in 2025 than in 2005. Over a fifth — 22% — of women in Idaho prisons are serving time for just a single drug possession sentence, compared to 10% of men. Nearly two-thirds of incarcerated women, 61%, have drug possession sentences on their record, versus 35% of men.

Drug court data obtained by researchers showed methamphetamine was the primary substance for 48% of participants, with heroin and other opioids at 20%. The report notes the criminal data analyzed did not distinguish between possession and trafficking charges.
A revolving door of probation failures
The report describes a system where people charged with drug possession “rarely receive a prison term” initially. Instead, they enter prison later, “after failing probation or retained jurisdiction.”
Drug possession was the least likely crime category to see charges reduced: only 6% of felony cases were amended to misdemeanors or lesser charges, based on 2022 data. Researchers attributed this to statutes offering fewer sentencing alternatives and inconsistent access to misdemeanor probation across counties.
Four counties — Ada, Canyon, Kootenai and Twin Falls — drove 87% of the inmate population growth.
Assault surge driven by domestic violence felony law
While drug possession fuels the volume, assault is the fastest-rising offense, jumping 30% over the decade. That outpaced alcohol-related crimes (24%) and drug crimes broadly (20%). One in five people in prison for assault were convicted of domestic violence, the fastest-growing assault category. Researchers linked the surge partly to a 2004 law that made any repeat domestic violence offense a felony and allowed out-of-state convictions to count toward that enhancement.
No recommendations, but a demand for more answers
Unusually for the Office of Performance Evaluations, the report offered no policy recommendations. Lawmakers on the oversight committee voted Wednesday to order a follow-up study. House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel, D-Boise, pressed analysts on the role of mandatory minimums. Christopher Shank, the report’s lead analyst, said most drug possession charges carried no mandatory minimum, and those that did typically involved the lowest tier.
An InvestigateWest investigation recently found people charged with trafficking under a 2024 fentanyl mandatory minimum law. Shank acknowledged it remains “an open question how often people who are convicted of trafficking are holding amounts that are intended for personal use.”
The governor’s response
In a letter sent before the report’s public release, Gov. Brad Little said the Idaho Department of Correction “has consistently tracked the trends outlined in this report and continues to work closely with law enforcement, the judiciary, and other partners to develop timely and responsible outcomes.”
“Idaho continues to be one of the safest places in the nation to live, work, and raise a family. Our quality of life reflects our strong investments in public safety.”
Little wrote.
The oversight committee’s next report will dig deeper into the sentencing structures and probation practices that keep Idaho’s prisons full while the rest of the country empties theirs.