In a column for WDIV ClickOnDetroit, columnist argues that Michigan’s chaotic football season has finally forced the university’s hand, pushing leadership to hire Texas A&M athletic director Trev Alberts with a mandate to fix a program that has collapsed to 5-5 under first-year coach Kyle Whittingham.
The hire came together in a hurry after Saturday’s 31-7 blowout loss at Oregon, WDIV reported. By Tuesday night, multiple outlets confirmed Alberts would leave College Station for Ann Arbor on a five-year deal worth more than $3 million annually, putting him in the top tier of sitting athletic directors, according to Yahoo Sports’ Ross Dellenger.
The expedited search — accelerated by incoming president C. Cybele Raver, who starts December 1 — signals how urgently the regents view the situation, the Detroit Free Press noted.
Whittingham’s credibility evaporated in November
Whittingham arrived in Ann Arbor with a reputation built on consistency at Utah, where he posted just one losing season in 19 years — 2024, when the Utes cycled through five quarterbacks. Michigan bet that track record would stabilize a roster returning 15 national-championship players and strengthened by high-profile transfers.
Instead, the Wolverines have played legitimately well once, the columnist wrote, and even that win required a Hail Mary against Western Michigan to avoid an Appalachian State-level embarrassment at home.
Trev Alberts' deal with Michigan is expected to put him in the top-3 among sitting athletic directors, sources tell @YahooSports – a five-year contract starting at more than $3 million annually. He will be expected to conduct an evaluation of Michigan Football immediately. https://t.co/vGM4gqvHOW
The Iowa loss crystallized the dysfunction. Michigan outgained the Hawkeyes by 145 yards and led for 59 minutes and 59 seconds, only to surrender a 99-yard kickoff return, commit eight penalties for 75 yards, and botch a fourth-down call that handed Iowa the win. A lifeless 180-yard offensive showing at Minnesota followed.
Then came the Indiana game, where the Wolverines didn’t allow a touchdown in regulation and still lost. The columnist wrote that offensive coordinator Jason Beck was so clearly in over his head that his removal was a no-brainer, yet Whittingham kept him until a shutout loss to a Michigan State team with one Big Ten win in two calendar years.
The columnist wrote that if the columnist filled this article with profanity, the columnist should probably not be allowed to publish directly to the site anymore.
But if nobody stops the columnist, and the columnist does it again tomorrow, and the next day, and the next day, it becomes the columnist’s boss’ fault, framing the coaching accountability as a management failure that now sits on the new AD’s desk.

Alberts brings a track record of decisive moves
The defining moment on Alberts’ résumé happened at Nebraska in 2022. Weeks before Scott Frost’s buyout would drop from $15 million to $7.5 million, Alberts fired his fellow Cornhusker legend midseason after a loss to Georgia Southern.
Frost had endured four losing seasons, but the decision — made despite shared history and Hall of Fame ties — showed a willingness to absorb short-term financial pain for long-term clarity. That same decisiveness is what Michigan is buying now.
At Texas A&M, Alberts oversaw four national championships across Olympic sports, though the football program under Jimbo Fisher and later Mike Elko has yet to break through. He also hired Matt Rhule at Nebraska, a move that has stabilized the Cornhuskers.
Michigan’s power brokers are betting that operational competence and a lack of institutional sentimentality will allow Alberts to make the call on Whittingham without the hesitation that often paralyzes blue-blood programs.
Whittingham’s public posture hasn’t helped
On Monday, before the Alberts news broke, Whittingham told reporters he had no idea who the AD finalists were. “I have no idea who the AD is going to be,” he said.
“I haven’t heard who the front runners or anything are, but the head coach and the AD have got to be in lockstep to be successful, and so I assume that will be the case. That’s what I’m hoping for.” Twenty-four hours later, Alberts was hired.
That gap — between the coach's public uncertainty and the administration's private speed — shows how isolated Whittingham has become. He also downplayed the importance of Michigan’s rivalry trophies this week, a tone-deaf remark at a program where the Little Brown Jug and Paul Bunyan Trophy are cultural currency.
Interim offensive coordinator Jim Harding, who spent 12 years with Whittingham at Utah, defended his intensity behind closed doors: “In my opinion, he’s as fiery, demanding — trust me, he has no problem yelling at me when I’m wrong,” Harding told the Free Press. “I think that to me shows that he still has the passion.”
Trev Alberts has signed an MOU to become the next AD at Michigan, per me and @DanWetzel. His buyout to leave Texas A&M is $4 million, which Michigan is expected to cover. https://t.co/ToyZ4C7S5R
Defensive coordinator Jay Hill, another Utah holdover, acknowledged the scrutiny is new for the players. “For the first time, Hill thought, the scrutiny may have finally worn down his unit in last week’s 31-7 loss to Oregon,” the Free Press reported. Whittingham turns 67 on Saturday. He was never viewed as a long-term answer — more a five-year bridge to stability. That bridge has collapsed.
The evaluation begins immediately
Dellenger reported that Alberts is expected to conduct an evaluation of the football program immediately. With Michigan sitting 14th in a weak Big Ten, the wins against Rutgers, Penn State, UTEP and Western Michigan carry little weight — those four opponents enter the week a combined 17-24, with eight of those wins belonging to Western Michigan. The only quality win came in Week 2 against Oklahoma.

Buyout numbers are unlikely to constrain Alberts. His salary alone signals institutional commitment, and the Free Press noted the regents called a special meeting Tuesday to advance the hire before Thursday’s scheduled board session.
The columnist argued the Spartans may have done Michigan a long-term favor: the home loss to Michigan State turned a “Fire Beck” chorus into a “Fire Whittingham” consensus, giving the new AD political cover to act decisively.
The University of Michigan, founded in 1817 as the Catholepistemiad, or University of Michigania, is the state’s oldest institution of higher education and a founding member of the Association of American Universities.
Between 1900 and 2022, university athletes earned 185 Olympic medals, including 86 gold. The university enrolled more than 54,181 students in 2021 and ranked third nationally in research expenditures, underscoring the scale of the enterprise Alberts now joins.
Michigan is targeting Texas A&M AD Trev Alberts to be its next athletic director, sources tell @YahooSports. Not finalized. U-M’s incoming president, C. Cybele Raver, called an emergency board meeting tonight as the school’s athletic director search closes in on a candidate.