Two years after Sanislo Elementary parents rallied to keep their West Seattle school open, Seattle Public Schools is proposing a merger with Highland Park Elementary that would shutter the Sanislo building, the Seattle Times reported.
Superintendent Ben Shuldiner met with families from both schools this week in the Highland Park cafeteria, where parents pressed him on teacher retention, principal seniority, and whether the district has exhausted alternatives like redrawing attendance boundaries. The meeting ran past its 90-minute limit as families continued questioning Shuldiner afterward.
“The district has to acknowledge the cost of continuing to do this to people,” said Megan Hamilton, a Sanislo parent. “Even if the plan doesn’t go through, the cost of this is catastrophic for certain families.”
Enrollment math drives the proposal
Seattle Public Schools enrollment has fallen from a peak near 100,000 in the 1960s to just under 50,000 today. Shuldiner said the merger plan, which could affect 21 schools, is driven by academic concerns rather than budget deficits alone. The district evaluated schools on single-teacher-per-grade staffing, building capacity, and facility conditions.
| School | Enrollment | Building size |
|---|---|---|
| Highland Park Elementary | 305 students | 76,200 sq ft |
| Sanislo Elementary | 122 students | 40,500 sq ft |
District projections show a combined enrollment of 427 students could fund a full-time social worker, art teacher, and music teacher — positions currently split or absent at both schools. All Sanislo teachers would receive spots at Highland Park, but only if enrollment justifies them; if families leave, staff could be reassigned elsewhere. Shuldiner promised no layoffs.

Community ties and transportation burdens
Manelin Phouang Pheth, a Sanislo alumna whose children attend the school, described the campus as “mommy’s school.” After a traumatic childbirth last year, she said the school’s nurse, social worker, and staff supported her children and checked on her recovery. “If we weren’t in such a tight community, I wouldn’t be able to have that,” she said.
For Trudi Skea, a merger would replace a four-minute walk with a 28-minute city bus ride covering 1.2 miles to Highland Park. “A larger, newer structure does not mean that you replace what is a healthy, nurturing, and necessary community school,” Skea said.
Leadership, boundaries, and deferred maintenance
Highland Park parents questioned why principal seniority would determine who stays after a one-year co-leadership period, which would favor Sanislo’s principal. Jen Jackson, a Highland Park parent and teacher, said the school’s leadership was why she enrolled her child there. Shuldiner called seniority the general practice but acknowledged further discussion is possible.
Jacky Paige, a Sanislo alumna with three children at the school, pointed to attendance boundaries that send nearby families to Lafayette Elementary and the Louisa Boren STEM K-8 option school. She asked whether redrawing boundaries could restore enrollment. Shuldiner said boundary changes would affect thousands more students than a merger.
Hamilton cited years of deferred maintenance — a leaky roof and poor bathroom conditions — as evidence of district neglect. “It feels like the district has deprioritized Sanislo on their basic repairs for so many years, that now the kids and these current families are bearing the cost of the neglect,” she said. Recent volunteer-painted murals and a refinished gym floor had given families hope after the last closure threat.
Some support merger with conditions; district confirms timeline
Not everyone opposed the plan. Gerard Gousman, a former Sanislo PTA president who transferred a child to Highland Park, supported consolidation but wanted Highland Park’s leadership protected and transportation provided for families who would struggle with the commute.
The advocacy group Save Seattle Schools, which tracks closure proposals, said the district should offer a “funded reboot” with clear milestones before pursuing mergers. SPS confirmed to KUOW that these communities are in potential merger discussions for the 2027–28 school year, with no final decisions made.
Seattle Public Schools, the state’s largest district with 104 schools and 49,226 students, traces its origins to a classroom taught by Catherine P. Blaine in January 1854.
The district operated 64 grammar schools and six high schools by 1919, and earned a national reputation as “exemplary” under Superintendent Frank B. Cooper from 1901 to 1922. It later faced a student boycott in 1966 and a 2007 U.S. Supreme Court case over the use of racial tie-breakers in student assignments.
Shuldiner plans to finish meeting with affected families by mid-December before making recommendations to the Seattle School Board. Public hearings are expected in January and February, with a board vote anticipated in late February or early March.