Wilmington Homeowner Faces $2,000 in Costs After Sidewalk Leak Ruled Private Duty

Wilmington homeowner Michael Ussery faces $2,000 in costs after a sidewalk leak was ruled his private responsibility.

“It’s just the way that it was handled was very, ‘Just go figure it out, just go figure it out,’” Michael Ussery told WWAYTV3.

He opened his Cape Fear Public Utility Authority bill on Oct. 23 and found a charge of $1,193 — roughly twelve times the $100 he typically pays for his property at 211 Princess Street in Wilmington.

The spike led him to his water meter, where he discovered a continuous leak. CFPUA crews pinpointed the break beneath the city sidewalk, about two feet from his building.

That small distance placed the leak on the property owner’s side of the meter, making Ussery responsible for the repair and the water lost. So far he has paid about $2,000 between the bill and a plumber, and his next statement already shows $1,600, wisevoter.com reported.

CFPUA’s policy draws a hard boundary at the meter: pipes between the main and the meter belong to the utility; the line running from the meter to the structure belongs to the owner.

Because the leak fell on the private side, the authority said it cannot make the repair. In a statement to WWAYTV3, CFPUA said staff investigated in October, confirmed the leak was on private property, and directed Ussery to the City of Wilmington for questions about removing the sidewalk pavement.

Photograph of a plain cast-iron water meter lid set into a weathered concrete sidewalk
Photo: wisevoter.com

The City of Wilmington confirmed it issued a permit for the work because the line sits in the public right-of-way. A city inspector has been assigned, and the city will inspect the sidewalk after the repair to ensure it meets code. Both agencies agree the financial burden rests with Ussery, but the homeowner said coordinating between the two entities has been nearly as frustrating as the bills themselves.

“When you’re dealing with something of this magnitude in a very centralized location that could affect a lot of people, it’s almost disrespectful to the community to not want to fix it,”

Michael Ussery, property owner, told WWAYTV3

The case illustrates a common friction point in older urban cores: service lines often run under public sidewalks before entering private buildings. A leak in that gray zone can saddle a homeowner with excavation costs, sidewalk restoration fees, and the full tab for lost water — even though the pipe sits beneath municipal concrete.

Wilmington, the seat of New Hanover County, was founded in the 1730s and named for Spencer Compton, Earl of Wilmington. By the late 19th century it was the state’s largest city and had a majority-Black, racially integrated government until a white supremacist coup in 1898 overthrew elected officials and drove Black residents from the city.

The downtown riverwalk, now a central gathering place, was developed as a tourist attraction in the late 20th century, and in 2020 Congress designated Wilmington the nation’s first World War II Heritage City.

Ussery must complete the repair under the city permit. The timeline for the sidewalk restoration remains unknown. His next billing cycle has already generated a $1,600 charge, wisevoter.com noted, and the meter will keep spinning until the line is fixed.