Xi Hosts Russia-China-US Summit in Shenzhen Focused on Symbolism Over Substance

History was made in Shenzhen on Thursday, but breakthroughs were not.

The optics were the substance. “Overall, very little of substance seems to have been accomplished … This summit appears to have been all about the symbolism and prestige value,” said Prof William Hurst of the University of Cambridge’s Centre for Geopolitics, speaking to The Guardian.

The host who held the cards

The joint statement — titled “The Russia-China-US Heads of State Declaration Toward Peace” — echoed long-standing Chinese positions on UN reform and multipolarity. “By reaching strategic consensus… (the countries) can catalyse broader multilateral cooperation and guide the reshaping of global order and values,” said Wang Yiwei, director of the Institute of International Affairs at Renmin University, according to RTÉ.

Xi’s calculus is domestic as much as diplomatic. He is trying to raise his profile before a key Communist Party conclave next year where he is expected to secure a fourth term. The summit let him stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the U.S. president without committing Chinese diplomats to the messy details of brokering peace in Ukraine or confronting Iran.

“Beijing has little interest in taking on the diplomatic risks of brokering an actual peace agreement in Ukraine or resolving the conflict with Iran,” a source told The Guardian. “That would entangle China in conflicts it would rather avoid.”

Putin’s rehabilitation

For the Russian leader, the venue itself was the victory. Since the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Putin has been treated as a pariah by Kyiv’s allies and had not attended an APEC summit in years.

Thursday he sat as an equal at a table the U.S. and Russia had both pushed for, while China was “reluctant,” Chim Lee of the Economist Intelligence Unit told RTÉ. “The fact that China affirms its value means that this set-up is very likely to continue,” Lee said, giving Trump less incentive to disrupt ties with either rival.

Putin Approaches Trump, Shakes Hands Ahead Of APEC Photo In Shenzhen, China; Xi Hosts Summit — CNBC-TV18

The Guardian quoted Hurst calling it “no Yalta moment, but it was certainly a solid public demonstration of Russia’s (and Putin’s) continuing relevance and power. It’s yet another example of Putin playing a poor hand to maximum effect.” Putin’s parting words to Xi, caught on Kremlin video, captured the mood: “Thank you for organising this. I don’t think anyone even expected everything to go so well.”

Trump’s photo op

The U.S. president arrived needing a win after midterm losses left him facing two years as a lame duck. He got a lavish welcome and a handshake with Putin he called “my friend” in a bilateral beforehand, Sky News reported.

But the declaration omitted the wars in Ukraine and Iran entirely, and the nuclear language fell far short of the “new, improved and modernized” treaty including China that Trump had promised. The last U.S.-Russia arms pact, New START, expired in February; China’s arsenal of roughly 600 warheads remains a fraction of the 5,000-plus held by Washington and Moscow, AP noted.

Putin Xi and Trump
Photo: BBC

“There was no new agreement,” said Chong Ja Ian of the National University of Singapore, speaking to RTÉ. The format “suggests the creation of conditions where Beijing, Moscow, and Washington call the shots for the rest of the world… (and) given Beijing’s close ties with Moscow, they could potentially put Washington on the back foot.”

Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association told AP: “We need more than diplomatic theater and photo opportunities between Xi, Putin and Trump. And one meeting will not likely produce dramatic breakthroughs.”

European allies were blindsided. “Mr Putin is not our friend and will never be,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said in a rejoinder to Trump. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called it “very incomprehensible” that a U.S. president would sit down with Putin.

Xi Jinping Hosts a Gala Dinner for Leaders at APEC Summit in China | Trump XI — CNBC-TV18

What the paper actually says

The declaration commits the three permanent Security Council members to UN reform “to enable it to respond more effectively to global challenges,” increased production and supply of refined petroleum products, respect for the immunities of state officials, and a pledge that the ICC “must not abuse its jurisdiction.”

On nukes, it reaffirms the Reagan-Gorbachev principle that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” and calls for “dialogue on reducing nuclear risks” — a formulation that commits no one to cuts, ceilings or verification.

Trump, boarding Air Force One, gave his own rating: “On a scale of zero to 10, I think it was a 12,” he told NBC News, per Sky News. The White House posted a clip of Trump helping Xi up an escalator; Chinese state TV aired footage of Trump appearing drowsy.

The next meeting of this troika, if it happens, will test whether the symbolism hardens into structure — or whether Thursday was the high-water mark of a format built for headlines, not treaties.