Romanian Lawyer Barred From ECHR for Two Years Over AI-Hallucinated Case Citations

A Romanian lawyer has been barred from the European Court of Human Rights for two years after a chamber found she filed submissions littered with fictitious case law generated by artificial intelligence tools.

The court’s president, Mattias Guyomar, approved the exclusion on November 13 following a reasoned proposal from the chamber hearing the underlying application, the court said in a media release Thursday. The lawyer, who was one of two representatives for the applicant, acknowledged using AI to draft the observations and described the resulting mistakes as “inaccuracies” and citation errors.

The chamber determined the filings contained “a pattern of numerous, repeated substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes,” according to the release. Those errors included references to nonexistent — “hallucinated” — cases, citations of fictitious paragraphs in genuine judgments, and the use of existing case law that was either irrelevant or directly contradicted the arguments it was cited to support.

“The lawyer’s admission that she had not sufficiently checked all the case law cited by her was an ‘understatement’,” the chamber wrote. It found that no checks were carried out for certain references, noting many errors were repetitive and would have been caught by a “cursory” check of the court’s own database.

The european court of human rights building in strasbourg france an

The sanction meets the “exceptional circumstances” threshold in the court’s rules for excluding an advocate, the chamber concluded. The decision does not prevent the lawyer from seeking restoration of her rights after the two-year period, and it does not affect the second representative in the case.

The ruling rests on a professional obligation the court says is embedded in both its own rules and Romania’s Legal Profession Act: lawyers must act as “reasonably competent” professionals and display a high level of professional prudence. That duty, the chamber said, required the lawyer to independently verify every case-law reference and argument produced by AI tools against authoritative sources before filing.

The court emphasized that the failure imposed real costs on the administration of justice. Judges and staff spent considerable time verifying the faulty observations, initiating disciplinary proceedings, and corresponding with the Romanian government and the Romanian National Bar Association — work the chamber deemed incompatible with its core functions under the European Convention on Human Rights.

A media release on Thursday stated that the court’s president, Mattias Guyomar, had approved a reasoned proposal from a chamber of the court for the lawyer’s exclusion, noting the chamber had invited comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government, and the Romanian National Bar Association before making its proposal.

The European Court of Human Rights, based in Strasbourg, France, was established on 21 January 1959 and decided its first case, Lawless v. Ireland, in 1960. It became a full-time institution on 1 November 1998 when Protocol 11 abolished the European Commission of Human Rights.

The lawyer’s rights of representation may be restored after the two-year period expires.