Zverev Faces Lawsuit From Ex-Partner Patea Over ‘Innocence Proven’ Claim

Alexander Zverev faces a civil lawsuit filed by his former partner Brenda Patea in Berlin that alleges he misrepresented the outcome of his domestic abuse trial, The Hamilton Spectator reported.

The suit, filed September 18 at Berlin Regional Court II, centers on an interview Zverev gave to French newspaper L’Équipe in June — the day after he won his first Grand Slam title at Roland Garros.

According to the complaint, first reported by the Bounces website, Zverev allegedly said “my innocence has been proven” regarding domestic abuse allegations. Patea’s legal team argues that claim breaches a settlement agreement tied to the termination of a criminal trial in June 2024 and constitutes a false factual assertion, The Athletic reported.

Court Terminates Zverev Trial Proceedings

In October 2023, a Berlin court issued a penalty order against Zverev for bodily harm against Patea, with whom he has a daughter. The order carried a fine of nearly $500,000. Zverev contested it, triggering a public trial that began in May 2024 at the Tiergarten District Court. On June 7, with the prosecutor’s consent, the court terminated proceedings.

The court later told BBC Sport the decision “is not a verdict and it is not a decision about guilt or innocence,” noting the witness wished to end the trial and the defendant agreed. A separate out-of-court settlement between Zverev and Patea was reached the same day Zverev reached the French Open final.

Zverev paid a monetary charge of over $218,000 split between legal costs and charity organizations as part of the criminal case resolution, The Athletic reported. The terms of the civil settlement with Patea have not been disclosed.

Patea’s lawyer, Dr. Michael Scheele, told BBC Sport: “He was not found guilty, but he was not acquitted and they signed an agreement in which he committed not to talk about this case any more.”

Dueling Legal Interpretations

The lawsuit seeks an injunction — enforceable by fines up to 250,000 euros — barring Zverev from repeating the “innocence proven” claim, plus damages for reputational impact.

Scheele told BBC Sport: “He was not found guilty, but he was not acquitted and they signed an agreement in which he committed not to talk about this case any more. Instead he has said that it has been proven that he was not guilty. It’s simply false.”

Alexander Zverev
Photo: bbc.co.uk

Zverev’s representatives, Berlin firm Schertz Bergmann, contend the statement is a protected opinion under Article 5(1) of the German Basic Law.

“Our client would merely have expressed his personal conviction that he had done everything in his power to refute the allegations made against him and that he considers his innocence to have been confirmed by the outcome of the criminal proceedings,” the firm said in a statement to BBC Sport. “The criminal proceedings were discontinued without any finding of guilt, and the presumption of innocence remains unaffected.”

Dr. Anna Sophie Heuchemer, also representing Zverev, told The Athletic the comments were “a permissible assessment of legal proceedings that have already reached a final, binding conclusion.”

She confirmed as of November 13 that neither Zverev nor his legal team had been formally served, though they would defend the action once served. A November 5 court order obtained by The Athletic outlines a written preliminary procedure granting Zverev one month from formal service to indicate his defense.

Prior Allegations and ATP Investigation

Patea was the second former girlfriend to accuse Zverev of domestic abuse. Olya Sharypova made allegations in 2020; she did not pursue charges. A 15-month ATP Tour investigation found there was “insufficient evidence” to substantiate Sharypova’s allegations and Zverev did not face disciplinary action. Zverev has consistently denied all allegations.

Following his French Open victory, Zverev addressed the terminated trial in a news conference. “That’s what dropping the case is. “They’re not going to drop the case if you’re guilty. I don’t know what translations you have, but that’s what it means. Done. We move on. I never ever want to hear another question about the subject again. That goes out to everybody,” Zverev said.”

Zverev officially notified of lawsuit by ex-partner in abuse case during the ATP Finals
Photo: thespec.com

“He was not found guilty, but he was not acquitted and they signed an agreement in which he committed not to talk about this case any more.”

Dr. Michael Scheele, lawyer for Brenda Patea, to BBC Sport

The civil case now hinges on whether a German court views Zverev’s “innocence proven” remark as a protected expression of opinion or a prohibited factual misrepresentation of a judicial outcome that explicitly declined to rule on guilt or innocence.

Disclaimer: The analytical insights and data provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.