The West Virginia Attorney General’s office asked the state Supreme Court on Friday to throw out a lawsuit demanding a total overhaul of the public school funding system, arguing lawmakers are immune from litigation over how they write the budget.
The motion, filed on behalf of Senate President Randy Smith and House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, landed just weeks after the ACLU of West Virginia took the rare step of suing directly in the high court.
At issue is Article XII, Section 1 of the state constitution, which commands the Legislature to provide a “thorough and efficient system of free schools.” The ACLU’s petition, filed in September on behalf of an unnamed Lincoln County student, argues the current seven-step funding formula — driven largely by enrollment counts — fails that mandate.
Enrollment has dropped by 8,270 students compared to the prior year, triggering a fiscal spiral that education officials say threatens 8 to 20 schools with closure or consolidation in the coming year.
The immunity shield
The state’s motion to dismiss leans heavily on legislative immunity, a doctrine that shields lawmakers from being sued for their legislative acts.
They also argue the student plaintiff lacks standing, citing a failure to demonstrate direct harm or verified taxpayer status. The Attorney General’s office represents the state officers named in the suit, including the governor and legislative leaders.
A race against the calendar
The legal maneuvering is playing out against a ticking legislative clock. State officials previously asked the court to pause the case until spring, giving lawmakers time to address funding during the regular session. The ACLU opposed that delay, calling it “neither efficient nor just” after years of broken promises.

“For years, West Virginia’s students and schools have been given false hope and empty promises concerning reform to the school aid formula, always being told that an adequately funded education is right around the next corner. Despite this, the promised relief has historically failed to materialize.”
ACLU of West Virginia attorneys, court filing
The civil liberties group warned that waiting for a legislative consensus risks producing reforms that still fall short of constitutional requirements. They argued that court intervention before the session would clarify obligations and guide lawmakers toward a compliant system. If the court does pause the case, the ACLU requested a preliminary injunction blocking the Department of Education and State Board of Education from approving school closures while the litigation idles.
The funding mechanics
West Virginia’s school aid formula relies heavily on student population, a model that punishes rural counties where enrollment is collapsing. The Department of Education rolled out a detailed framework last month intended as a starting point for legislators, but the ACLU contends the structural deficiencies run deeper than any formula tweak can fix.
Special education costs have blown a massive hole in local budgets, driving the closure wave that has hollowed out communities across the state.
Attorney General JB McCuskey’s office, representing the state officers, framed the defense around separation of powers. The ACLU counters that the constitutional mandate is judicially enforceable and that the court has a duty to intervene when the political branches fail.
The American Civil Liberties Union has operated in West Virginia since its founding year of 1920, when it sent lawyers to represent miners jailed for organizing. In 1943, the affiliate won a landmark U.S. Supreme Court victory for West Virginia school children who objected to a compulsory flag salute on religious grounds.
Today, ACLU of West Virginia describes itself as the state’s foremost advocate of individual rights, working as a nonpartisan, nonprofit membership organization across courts, legislatures, and communities.
The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on the motion to dismiss or the request for a stay. The next regular legislative session begins in January.