Albany County Sheriff Craig D. Apple Sr. Considers Early Resignation to Install Democratic Pick

Albany County Sheriff Craig D. Apple Sr. said Wednesday he is considering resigning before his term expires at the end of 2027 to install the Democratic Party’s endorsed candidate as acting sheriff ahead of next year’s elections.

The maneuver would hand the party’s pick the power of incumbency months before the June primary, a move Apple described as a way to “start my retirement” after 14 years in office, Times Union reported. His term runs through the end of 2027.

“I don’t have 13 months in me,” Apple said in a text message Wednesday, responding to questions about his plans for the remainder of his tenure. “That’s a thought I have. Not saying I’m going to do that, but it would allow me to start my retirement.”

The succession mechanism

The plan hinges on a specific provision of state law. The undersheriff is first in the line of succession; if Apple appoints the endorsed candidate to that role and then resigns, that person becomes acting sheriff. Undersheriff Michael Monteleone has already retired, and another member of the office is currently serving in an acting capacity, Apple confirmed Wednesday.

Albany County Sheriff Craig D. Apple Sr. Considers Early Resignation to Install Democratic Pick
Photo: yahoo.com

State law also empowers the governor to appoint a sheriff to fill a vacancy, subject to state Senate confirmation. That alternative route introduces a variable the party structure cannot control.

The anointed candidate

Top county Democrats have already lined up behind Bethlehem Police Chief Gina Cocchiara. County Executive Daniel P. McCoy, County Legislature Chair Joanne Cunningham, and Apple himself have endorsed her. All three attended a fundraiser for Cocchiara Wednesday night.

Primary challenger watches the calendar

Former Bethlehem Police Commander Adam Hornick has expressed interest in the race but has not formally declared. He said Wednesday he is “aware of the nomination process and electoral cycle” and is “considering those deadlines in any decision I make.”

The Albany County Democratic Committee will make its endorsements in February. Chair Jake Crawford said the decision flows through candidate interviews, questionnaires, and a series of internal committees before a full committee vote. The endorsement unlocks party resources for petition signatures and fundraising — advantages that grow much larger if the designee already holds the office.

Albany County, one of the original twelve counties created by the Province of New York on November 1, 1683, once stretched north to the parallel of 45 degrees latitude and included all of present-day Bennington County, Vermont. Its boundaries contracted steadily as the state carved new counties from its territory, reaching its current 530 square miles on March 3, 1888. The county seat is Albany, the state capital, and the 2020 census recorded a population of 314,848.

What remains unresolved

Apple has not set a date for his departure. The governor’s appointment power remains a live alternative if the party’s succession plan stalls or if the vacancy arrives on a timeline the Senate cannot confirm. Hornick's decision on whether to enter the race — and whether to challenge an appointed incumbent — will shape the primary race in the months ahead.