“We are trained for every operation we’ve taken part in, and I think the troopers were professional and did a great job,” Col. Matt Perry told the joint Government Operations Subcommittee on Wednesday.
The Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security appeared before lawmakers for a routine sunset hearing, a proceeding meant to review the agency’s cybersecurity, driver’s license audits and evidence storage. Instead, the session collapsed into a raw confrontation over immigration enforcement, the scope of highway patrol authority and the fallout from a six-night operation in South Nashville that netted nearly 200 detentions.
Since the department began refusing licenses and renewals to non-citizens with legal status last month — citing a new state law — a Nashville judge has ordered the state to ignore that law through Dec. 8 while a lawsuit challenging it proceeds.
When Rep. John Ray Clemmons, D-Nashville, asked whether the department would issue licenses uniformly in the meantime, Assistant Commissioner Russell Shoup declined to answer, citing the ongoing litigation. “In our opinion, we’re very limited on what we can say,” Shoup said. “Our role is to follow the law of state law and the federal law, and so we’re attempting to do that in our capacity.”
Clemmons pressed again. “So you can’t speak or reassure the people of Tennessee right now who are legal residents that they are not going to be unlawfully denied their licenses, unable to work, unable to take their children to school, get to church in any way whatsoever right now?” Shoup held his ground.
The hearing’s sharpest edge concerned the Tennessee Highway Patrol’s involvement in a sweeping South Nashville raid earlier this year. Clemmons said the operation involved around 600 traffic stops and resulted in nearly 200 detentions while actual traffic enforcement plummeted.
“A majority of the people who were pulled over, whether it’s for a broken taillight, whether it was for speeding, had no criminal history, yet they were incarcerated for some length of time, some still causing them incredible cost, expense, stress, trauma,” Clemmons said. “That’s my concern.”
Perry defended the troopers’ conduct, saying they made probable-cause stops only to enforce state law. He noted that some troopers received federal immigration training through a 287(g) agreement with ICE — an agreement that did not exist until after the operation in question — and said the department was focused on being “a good partner” to other agencies.
Perry repeatedly cited litigation, including a lawsuit by the Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition seeking to end the ICE agreement, as grounds to avoid substantive answers.
State Sen. Sara Kyle, D-Memphis, echoed Clemmons, saying his concerns “nailed” the sentiment in Shelby County, where THP has worked with ICE and other agencies for more than a year, including involvement in a nightclub immigration sting in September that resulted in more than 100 detentions.
“Any message you can carry back, or anybody you can call from federal government down to state government, the message is: please stop. We don’t want the task force down there in Memphis,” Kyle said.
Perry did not respond to Kyle’s statement. Rep. Justin Lafferty, R-Knoxville, snapped back on the department’s behalf. “I know you guys can’t talk about some of the stuff going on because of the legal status or what have you, but the mischaracterization that you all are ‘kidnapping’ people is appalling to me. So I would just like to get that on the record,” Lafferty said.
The Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security was established in 1939 by the Tennessee General Assembly to exercise authority over the Highway Patrol. The Office of Homeland Security was created in April 2003 by an executive order from then-Governor Phil Bredesen in the aftermath of the September 11, 2001 attacks. The department has issued handgun permits through the Highway Patrol since October 1996, assuming the role previously held by local sheriffs’ offices.
The sunset audit itself raised concerns about cybersecurity, driver’s license reviews and THP evidence storage. On each issue, the department appeared to have clear instructions on how to address the finding, though systems for license reviews and evidence storage already exist and are not being implemented routinely. The subcommittee ultimately recommended a four-year extension for the department, a decision the full committee and legislature will vote on later.