Albany County Sheriff Weighs Early Exit to Hand Democratic Pick Incumbency Advantage

Albany County Sheriff Craig D. Apple Sr. is weighing an early exit that would hand the Democratic Party’s pick for sheriff the power of incumbency months before voters go to the polls.

Apple, who has held the office since 2011, told the Times Union on Wednesday he is “considering” a plan to resign within the next several months and install the party’s endorsed candidate as undersheriff, positioning them to take over in an acting capacity. “That’s a thought I have,” Apple said in a text message. “Not saying I’m going to do that, but it would allow me to start my retirement.”

The maneuver would shortcut the final 13 months of a term that expires at the end of 2027. “I don’t have 13 months in me,” Apple said. Undersheriff Michael Monteleone had retired, and another member of the office is currently serving in that role in an acting capacity.

The succession mechanics

Under state law, the undersheriff is next in the line of succession in the sheriff’s office. If Apple appoints the endorsed Democrat to that post and then steps down, that person becomes acting sheriff immediately — collecting the title, the badge, and the visibility that comes with running the department heading into a June primary.

The governor also holds appointment power for a vacancy, subject to state Senate confirmation, but the undersheriff route would keep the transition entirely inside the county.

Albany County Sheriff Weighs Early Exit to Hand Democratic Pick Incumbency Advantage
Photo: yahoo.com

Who stands to benefit

Daniel P. McCoy, Joanne Cunningham and Apple have already endorsed Cocchiara. All three were scheduled to be at a fundraiser for Cocchiara Wednesday night.

“Would welcome the opportunity,” Cocchiara’s campaign manager, Libby Post, told Yahoo News when asked about the acting-sheriff scenario.

Adam Hornick has expressed interest but has not formally declared. He said he is “aware of the nomination process and electoral cycle” and is “considering those deadlines in any decision I make.”

The party calendar

Jake Crawford said endorsements for county offices will be made in February. The process runs through candidate interviews, questionnaires, and a series of internal committees before a recommendation reaches the full committee for a vote.

That endorsement carries concrete advantages: party machinery for petition signatures, fundraising infrastructure, and now, potentially, the office itself.

What remains unresolved

Apple stressed the plan is not final. The timing of any resignation, the identity of the appointee, and whether the party’s February endorsement aligns with Apple’s preference are all open questions. Hornick’s decision on whether to enter the race formally could also shift the calculus.

Apple began his law-enforcement career in 1987 and has led the office since his first election in 2011. He created several signature programs, including the Sheriff’s Heroin Addiction Recovery Program (SHARP), the Soldier On initiative for veterans, and the Sheriff’s Inmate Fire Training (SHIFT) program. In 2022 he announced a run for the New York State Senate in the 43rd District but later withdrew.

“Not saying I’m going to do that,” Apple said of the succession plan.