An Old-Fashioned Family Murder,” at the Richmond Hill Barn Theatre through November 22

Thunder rolls, lightning flashes, and a grandiose popinjay in a smoking jacket bellows for murder to open An Old-Fashioned Family Murder at the Richmond Hill Barn Theatre. Running through November 22, Joe DiPietro’s 2024 comedic mystery brings a fresh script to Geneseo, Illinois, blending Golden Age detective tropes with sharp modern humor.

Helmed by Jonathan Grafft, the production leans heavily into the traditions popularized by Agatha Christie. Audiences encounter a familiar playbook featuring a will-amending patriarch, inheritance-hopeful heiresses, and opportunistic leeches.

Familiar Faces Return to the Stage

Mike Kelly stars as the best-selling mystery author Arthur Whittington. Kelly previously appeared in The 39 Steps at the same venue in 2019, where he played Professor Jordan. Grafft previously took on the role of accidental hero Hannay in that same 2019 production, reuniting two veterans of classic theatrical thrillers.

The cast also features Shyan DeVoss as the flirty, engaged aspiring actor Clarice. DeVoss brings past dramatic credits including Witness for the Prosecution and 12 Angry Jurors to the stage. Jesslyn Cohen plays her quieter sister, Dotty, who owns all of Whittington’s books.

A Festive Backdrop and Regional Setting

Set in 1943 within the Pacific Northwest, the mansion’s drawing room features understated Christmas decorations suited for a season-ending production. Jackie Skiles portrays the eager reader Mrs. Peck, who gets trapped by the storm alongside other unfortunate guests. Samuel Carrington stars as Detective Peck, attempting to live up to the reputation of his detective father on his first murder investigation.

Tickets and showtimes for the final production of the 2026 season are available through the Richmond Hill Barn Theatre website or by calling (309)944-2244.

Richmond marks 20th anniversary of Harvey family murders — 12 On Your Side