Arkansas Attorney Alleges Former Bar Exam Director Blocked Him Repeatedly

Matthew Draper spent eight years failing the Arkansas bar exam. He passed Mississippi’s on his first try.

The contrast landed hard this month when prosecutors charged Nancie Givens, the former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs, with 65 felonies. The indictment alleges she tampered with bar exam scores over a five-year span, failing candidates who should have passed and passing others who should have failed, KATV reported.

Draper believes he was one of them. He sat for the Arkansas exam roughly eight times between 2012 and 2020, he told KATV, each attempt costing him an application fee he never recovered. “Every time I turned something in this lady’s email and me telling me they’re not getting it,” Draper said, describing a cycle of missing documents and resubmissions that kept him from even sitting for the test.

Arkansas Attorney Alleges Former Bar Exam Director Blocked Him Repeatedly
Photo: newzly.net

When he finally made it to the exam room, Givens required him to sign an acknowledgment form unlike anything he had seen elsewhere. It stipulated that if he passed, he would not necessarily be admitted to the bar and his name would not appear on the public pass list. Instead, Givens would personally email him the result.

“I had to sign one of these every time I took the bar exam all the way up until 2020,” Draper told KATV. Those emails never brought good news. “The emails she would send me would tell me I didn’t pass. And she would say my scores… my scores would be in the mail, but I never actually received those scores in the mail,” he said.

The charges against Givens cover 2020 through 2025, but Draper’s experience stretches back to 2012, suggesting the alleged scheme may have operated longer than the indictment captures. As secretary of the State Board of Law Examiners, Givens held a gatekeeping role with minimal oversight. Draper questions how one person could manipulate outcomes for years without detection.

“If one person was able to even do something like this to this magnitude… that’s a lack of checks and balances right there,” he told KATV. “I mean, that kind of just looks like somebody else was either not paying attention and there should have been… a better system to where this couldn’t have been able to happen.”

Attorney says former Arkansas bar exam director repeatedly prevented him from passing — KATVchannel7

Newzly, summarizing the KATV report, noted the headline identifies the accusation as Draper’s account rather than an established finding. The outlet cautioned that the available material does not specify the exact mechanism of interference — whether grading, administration, or another part of the process — and that no examination results or correspondence have been released to corroborate the claim independently.

For Draper, the toll was existential. “Going in there when your wife’s got a kid on the way, and you know, you’re like, okay, I have to get this done this time,” he told KATV.

“Like, I’m not going to be able to provide for us unless I make this happen. And all the time I put into like studying and just to in my mind, fall short, doubt myself… And it’s a… it’s nice to feel vindicated.”

He is now considering a lawsuit against Givens and has arranged to speak with Little Rock attorneys. He also hopes to share his story with prosecutors handling the criminal case.