Advance Colorado filed a lawsuit Thursday in Denver District Court asking a judge to block Amendment 87, the graduated income tax measure voters approved this month with 51.7% support.
The conservative nonprofit, which does not disclose its donors, filed the suit on behalf of Republican state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer and Byron Pelton of Sterling. It argues the measure violated the Colorado Constitution by bundling two distinct changes — repealing the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights’ flat-tax requirement and enacting a new graduated rate structure in statute — into a single ballot question, CPR News reported.
“The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned,” Kirkmeyer, who sits on the Joint Budget Committee, said in a statement released by Advance Colorado.
Chris deGruy Kennedy, president of the Bell Policy Center, called the lawsuit a distraction and said Advance Colorado will throw up every little barrier it can to protect its rich donors from having to pay more taxes, adding that he does not worry about it from a legal perspective at all, the Greeley Tribune reported.

The legal theory shifts from single-subject to TABOR
This is the third legal attempt to stop the measure. Conservatives previously challenged Amendment 87 under the state’s single-subject rule, arguing it combined unrelated topics. The state Title Board and the Colorado Supreme Court rejected that argument, allowing the measure on the ballot. In late October, the Supreme Court also rejected a challenge targeting petition-gathering signatures, the Greeley Tribune reported.
The new suit takes a different tack. It contends that TABOR itself requires a tax increase to be presented to voters as a standalone question, separate from the constitutional amendment needed to delete the flat-tax mandate. “Under TABOR, the lawsuit says, Amendment 87 should have been broken into two ballot questions: one to increase taxes, and one to delete TABOR’s prohibition on graduated income tax brackets,” The Colorado Sun reported.
Blue Book table shows conflicting tax impacts
The complaint also targets the state’s nonpartisan Blue Book voter guide. It alleges a table in the guide incorrectly told thousands of taxpayers earning between $500,000 and $1 million in federal taxable income that they would receive an average $284 tax cut. The lawsuit claims those filers will actually see an average $2,651 increase, the Greeley Tribune reported.
The Sun previously reported the table is confusing but not necessarily inaccurate. The discrepancy stems from methodology: Amendment 87 raises taxes on Colorado taxable income above $500,000. Many high earners live in the state part-time, so their Colorado taxable income is far lower than their federal figure, resulting in a tax cut under the new brackets for that specific cohort.

Where the money goes: Polis’s Medicaid warning
Advance Colorado argues the ballot language misled voters on spending. The suit quotes Gov. Jared Polis telling the Joint Budget Committee on Nov. 12 that without Medicaid cost containment, “within three years, it all goes to Medicaid.” Zero for education, zero for actually making people healthier, zero for early childhood,” Chalkbeat Colorado reported.
Colorado faces a more than $1 billion budget deficit driven by Medicaid growth. Polis warned that the new revenue — projected at roughly $2 billion annually by 2028 — would be entirely absorbed by the healthcare program unless lawmakers act. Bell Policy Center’s Chris deGruy Kennedy countered that he expects a “very healthy increase in funding” for all three priority areas: K-12 education, healthcare, and early childhood.
Advance Colorado’s countermeasure
On the same day it filed suit, Advance Colorado announced it had submitted several ballot proposals for 2027 aimed at reversing Amendment 87. One proposal would exempt people and businesses earning $100,000 or less from income tax entirely, while restoring the flat 4.4% rate for income above that threshold. President Michael Fields argued the state could still spend per capita roughly what Nevada, North Carolina, and New Hampshire spend despite the revenue loss.
“We have a government that has been growing faster than wages every year and that’s not sustainable,” Fields said.
Voters rejected Advance Colorado’s competing measure this year, Proposition 136, which would have capped the income tax rate at 4.4%. It failed with 52.8% voting no.
Barbara Kirkmeyer, a Republican from Weld County, has served in the Colorado Senate since 2021 after 19 years as a county commissioner. She ran as the GOP nominee for the new 8th Congressional District in 2022, losing to Yadira Caraveo by 1,632 votes, and is a candidate in the 2026 gubernatorial race. As a senator she sits on the Joint Budget Committee and serves as vice chair of the Legislative Interim Committee on School Finance.
Case awaits Denver court ruling
The Attorney General’s office and Gov.-elect Phil Weiser declined to comment on the pending litigation. A Polis administration spokesperson also declined to comment. The case now sits before a Denver District Court judge, with the state’s new tax structure scheduled to take effect unless the court intervenes.