Robert Lisle Johns, the bankruptcy trustee and state auditor’s office employee indicted alongside West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt, resigned his federal post Tuesday, effective immediately, WCHS reported.
The resignation, which surfaced in court dockets Thursday, pulls Johns from seven pages of active Chapter 7 and Chapter 11 cases across the Northern and Southern Districts of West Virginia. The U.S. Trustee Program moved the same day to secure the bank accounts Johns controlled and has begun assigning successor trustees to comb those estates for irregularities.
“At the time of the indictment, Mr. Johns served as a bankruptcy trustee subject to USTP supervision. The USTP took immediate action to protect the bankruptcy estates by securing the respective bank accounts that Mr. Johns controlled,” said Matthew Nies, spokesman for the Department of Justice Office of Public Affairs.
“Mr. Johns has resigned from all open cases in which he served as a bankruptcy trustee and is not receiving new case assignments. The USTP will work in coordination with the successor trustees assigned to his open cases to determine whether any irregularities exist.”
The indictment map
Federal prosecutors allege Hunt used the authority of his office to steer nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties to a business entity tied to Johns, overriding career employees in the Auditor’s Land Division who had ruled the purchases ineligible because required payments and paperwork were never filed on time. Hunt personally signed deeds for eight properties on March 28, 2025, and a ninth on June 6, 2025.

Johns, 66, was hired as special counsel in the Auditor’s office in June 2025 — months after the first batch of deeds was issued. He also owns the land where Hunt’s private used-car dealership, After Hours Used Auto, operates, WCHS noted. The indictment charges Johns with nine federal counts; his initial appearance and arraignment before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dwane Tinsley is set for 3 p.m. November 30.
Four others charged
The case reaches beyond the two men. Also indicted, according to WVVA:
- David Keith Cole, 57, deputy chief of staff in Hunt’s office and office manager of Hunt’s private law firm;
- Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, general counsel for the State Auditor’s Office;
- Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, of Hurricane, an auditor’s office employee accused of submitting falsified timecards that billed the state for hours worked at Hunt’s private law firm, with Hunt and Cole allegedly validating the fraud.
Hoffmann’s bank-fraud count carries a maximum penalty of 30 years in prison, up to five years of supervised release, and a $1 million fine, WVVA reported.
The investigation began with a tip from individuals concerned about how processes were being carried out inside the Auditor’s office, U.S. Attorney Moore Capito told WVVA. “Every time that you hear something it doesn’t mean a case, but we look into every single one of them,” Capito said.
Gov. Patrick Morrisey has called on lawmakers to consider impeachment and referred a separate DMV investigation of Hunt’s dealership to Capito’s office. House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, the West Virginia Republican Party, the West Virginia Democratic Party, and Treasurer Larry Pack have all demanded Hunt’s resignation. Hunt, a Republican elected in 2024, has refused, calling the indictment “an insult to the principles on which this country was founded.”
“This is about the law. The law is blind. The law applies to anybody in the state of West Virginia regardless of your title or your position,” Capito said.

What happens to the properties — and the bankruptcy dockets
The nine deeds remain recorded. Prosecutors allege they were stolen from the lawful owners, but no court has yet ordered them unwound. Meanwhile, the U.S. Trustee’s office faces a quieter crisis: successor trustees must now reconstruct case histories Johns managed, verify asset distributions, and assure creditors that no estate funds were diverted. That work begins with the bank accounts the Trustee Program froze this week.
Johns’s arraignment on November 30 will be the first public procedural step in the criminal case.