Barkin: US and Virginia Workforce Remain Flat

The American economy is currently moving forward, but it is doing so with a distinct lack of new hands on deck.

While the U.S. gross domestic product grew by 3.4% in the third quarter—a notable jump from the 2.2% seen in the second—this expansion is being driven almost entirely by productivity gains rather than a swelling pool of workers. According to Virginia Business, the national labor force has essentially hit a ceiling, a trend mirrored closely within the Commonwealth of Virginia.

Tom Barkin, president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, laid out this reality during a fireside chat in Charlottesville on Thursday.

Sitting down with Aubrey Layne, the former state commerce and trade secretary, Barkin explained that the nation’s remarkably low unemployment rate of 4.1%—part of a 100-year streak of keeping joblessness below 4.5%—is deceptive. It is not necessarily a sign of a booming, overflowing job market, but rather a reflection of a supply-side bottleneck.

“It doesn’t take many new jobs to keep unemployment levels steady.”

Barkin told the audience that the workforce isn’t growing because the retirement of baby boomers is coinciding with a sharp decline in new entrants. Compounding this is a significant drop in immigration, which he noted has plummeted from 2 million people three years ago to “now basically zero.”

The Housing Vulnerability in Virginia

For Virginia, the stakes are tied directly to the ground beneath its residents’ feet. “Virginia's lack of affordable housing is a vulnerability,” Tom Barkin, president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond said.

He said that when he travels north toward the borders of West Virginia or crosses into North Carolina, the difference in housing availability is stark. He described seeing thousands of affordable homes just across the border, a disparity that influences where people choose to settle and work.

Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Work

Despite widespread anxiety regarding automation, Barkin remains measured about the immediate impact of artificial intelligence on the workforce. While AI is already transforming how businesses handle coding, call centers, and compliance, he argued that it has not yet sparked a wave of unemployment. The reason, he suggested, is simple: companies are currently making enough profit that they are not eager to initiate layoffs.

However, he cautioned that this could shift if the technology advances to handle higher-level tasks. His primary concern is not a total lack of jobs, but a mismatch of skills.

He said that displaced computer coders may not be interested in, or trained for, the healthcare roles that remain in high demand. The challenge for the economy, as he described it, is managing the transition between the jobs we have today and the roles that will emerge tomorrow.

“I'm not sure that all these computer coders are dying to become healthcare workers,” Tom Barkin, president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond said.

Economic Metric Recent Performance
US GDP Growth (Q2) 2.2%
National Unemployment Rate 4.1%
Target Federal Funds Rate 3.75% – 4%

The Consumer Sentiment Gap

The disconnect between strong economic data and the public’s perception of the economy remains a hurdle. While consumer spending continues to prop up 70% of the economy, many individuals report feeling significant financial strain due to persistent inflation. Barkin acknowledged this tension, noting that even when people have steady income, the rising cost of living makes them feel less secure.

As an alternate member of the Federal Open Market Committee, Barkin is now looking toward the next policy moves. With the federal funds rate currently held at a target of 3.75% to 4% following the October meeting, the central bank remains focused on its goal of bringing inflation down.

Looking ahead to the December meeting, the path forward remains a subject of debate as officials weigh incoming data on inflation and global events.

The question of how these disparate factors—stagnant workforce growth, the rise of AI, and the high cost of housing—will coalesce remains open. Whether the economy can continue to balance these pressures without tipping into a deeper labor crisis is the issue that will dominate the coming months.