Douglas Jose Centeno-Vargas, a 31-year-old former Bridgeport resident, was booked into police custody late Tuesday night, marking a rare resolution to the October 2025 homicide of 24-year-old Evelyn Rayo-Mairena.
The suspect was transported to Bridgeport Police Headquarters from a jail near Houston, Texas, after being flown from Nicaragua by U.S. Marshals several weeks ago.
The case, which authorities describe as an exceptionally complex international pursuit, centers on a violent encounter on Black Rock Avenue on the night of Oct. 21, 2025. According to reports, investigators believe Centeno-Vargas shot Rayo-Mairena inside his vehicle before leaving her one-year-old daughter in a car seat on a nearby porch and dragging the victim onto the pavement.
The infant, who was found with a bloodied blanket, was physically unharmed and is now living with her father. The victim and the suspect were both emigrants from Nicaragua and were known to be friends, according to details provided by WFSB.
Following the shooting, police allege that an unidentified driver transported Centeno-Vargas to John F. Kennedy International Airport, from which he fled to El Salvador before returning to his native Nicaragua.

Securing the suspect’s return was a major challenge for law enforcement because there is no formal extradition treaty between the United States and Nicaragua. The arrest was only made possible through the collaboration of the Bridgeport Police Department, the U.S. Marshals Service, Interpol, and the U.S. Departments of State and Justice.
“There is no extradition treaty between the United States and Nicaragua. This is an extremely rare and remarkable outcome. It is the result of unrelenting work by the Bridgeport Police Homicide Detectives, Major Crimes Detectives, the United States Marshals Service, Interpol, the Bridgeport Police Fugitive Unit, the United States Departments of State and Justice and Ms. Rayo-Mairena’s family,” said Detective Jeffrey Holtz of the Bridgeport Police.
The investigation into the circumstances of the flight remains active. While Centeno-Vargas is now in custody, authorities have not yet identified the person who drove him to the airport immediately following the incident, as reported by NBC Connecticut. The suspect faces charges of murder, risk of injury to a minor, and tampering with physical evidence, and is currently held on a $4 million bond.

Bridgeport Police Chief Roderick Porter expressed confidence that the judicial process will address the gravity of the crime. The case highlights the logistical and diplomatic challenges inherent in pursuing fugitives who flee to countries without established extradition agreements. For the family of Rayo-Mairena, the return of the suspect represents a necessary, if difficult, step toward accountability.
“The Bridgeport Police Department is confident Evelyn Rayo-Mairena, her daughter and the rest of her family here and in Nicaragua will receive the justice they deserve. I am extremely proud of our detectives,” Chief Porter said.