Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Xavier Worthy faced a wave of criticism after watching a late onside kick bounce into the hands of Atlanta Falcons receiver Chris Blair on Sunday, a miscue that marked the first successful onside-kick recovery of the NFL season.
Special teams coordinator Dave Toub took the blame Thursday, telling the Kansas City Star he should have called a timeout or adjusted Worthy’s alignment after noticing the Falcons lined up wide. “I’m going to blame myself because we thought that the kicker was going to kick something by the numbers,” Toub said.
“That’s my fault. And I’m laying in bed thinking about that all the time, that I could have been a lot different for him. He took the brunt of the blame on that thing.”
The production gap
The onside kick became a flashpoint because Worthy’s offensive output has stalled. He played 57 snaps against Atlanta — more than any other Chiefs pass-catcher — yet finished without a catch on three targets. By comparison, newcomer Josh Downs turned 11 snaps into four catches for 53 yards and a touchdown. Worthy has 278 receiving yards at the season’s midpoint.

Head coach Andy Reid pushed back on the raw numbers Wednesday, arguing the Falcons schemed specifically to neutralize Worthy’s 4.21-second speed. “You can see how they played him, and teams know he can run,” Reid said. “So they’re either going to bang him around and try to put somebody over the top of him, and then you use somebody else.”
Mahomes trusts the process
Quarterback Patrick Mahomes echoed that support. “He knows how much we trust in him and how much I trust in him, and he’s made big plays for us in multiple years here,” Mahomes said. “Not everybody’s going to have the stats every single game, but if you stay within the process of the game throughout the entire season, those games come.”
NextGen Stats show Worthy averages 3.8 yards of separation when targeted, ninth among all receivers. He flashed late last season — 157 yards and two touchdowns in the Super Bowl, then seven catches for 73 yards against the Chargers after Rashee Rice’s injury — but a shoulder injury on the third offensive snap of 2025 may have altered his trajectory.

Contract clock ticking
Kansas City must decide this spring whether to exercise Worthy’s fifth-year option for 2028. He becomes extension-eligible after the 2026 season. At 23, he is younger than rookie Cyrus Allen by roughly two and a half months, a reminder that his third NFL year is still early in a typical development curve.
Xavier Worthy, born in 2003, attended Central East High School in Fresno, California, where he was selected for the 2021 All-American Bowl before the game was canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic. He originally committed to the University of Michigan before flipping to the University of Texas at Austin, where he broke freshman school records with 981 receiving yards and 12 touchdowns in 2021, marks previously held by Roy Williams.
At the 2024 NFL Combine, Worthy ran a 4.21-second 40-yard dash, breaking John Ross’s record of 4.22 seconds. Selected 28th overall by Kansas City, he scored two touchdowns on his first two NFL touches in the season opener against Baltimore.
In Super Bowl LIX, his 157 receiving yards set a Super Bowl rookie record, surpassing the 109-yard mark shared by Torry Holt and Chris Matthews, and he became the first Texas Longhorn to score a touchdown in the Super Bowl.
Worthy declined to speak with reporters Thursday, saying he needed to get to the JUGS machine early. The Chiefs host Arizona next, a matchup Reid hopes can serve as a get-right game. “We’re not down on him,” Reid said. “He can do all this stuff, and I hope he’s not worried about all that other thing and just keep being him.”