Chris Columbus fired the only actor he has ever cut from a film in the first four days of shooting Home Alone, a decision that reshaped one of the most profitable comedies in history and left the dismissed performer waiting three decades for a promised callback that never came.
The director, now 68, told the Wildmen podcast this week that the studio refused to pay for Daniel Stern, his first choice to play Marv opposite Joe Pesci’s Harry. “I conceived of Dan Stern and Joe Pesci in this movie as the bad guys. And they said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci,’” Columbus said.
The replacement, a younger actor Columbus declined to name, lacked chemistry with Pesci. “We did a screen test and they were horrible,” Columbus said. “I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful. And I had to— that’s the only person I ever had to fire.”
That actor was Daniel Roebuck, who confirmed the firing on the What a Character! podcast in 2023. Roebuck said he was let go after four days and described a “wettest handshake of my life” from writer-producer John Hughes. “It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn’t want me to be there. It was all so obvious,” Roebuck told the podcast.
He also said Columbus promised a role in a future film. “Chris Columbus said I will give you a great part of my next movie,” Roebuck said. “Now, I notice he’s done 20 since then and he’s never called. But what really was disappointing was, you know, no one ever just told me the truth.”

Columbus’s account reveals how a single line-item negotiation — “You only get one” — nearly derailed the central dynamic of a film that has grossed more than $476 million worldwide. The director wanted Stern, a veteran of Diner and Breaking Away, but the studio would only greenlight Pesci’s salary.
The unnamed replacement failed the screen test with Pesci, forcing Columbus to make the solitary firing of his career. Stern was eventually hired, and the Pesci-Stern pairing became the template for the franchise’s slapstick violence.
Columbus framed the dismissal as a professional necessity, telling the Wildmen podcast he left the door open: “We’ll work together at some point.” Roebuck’s 2023 interview paints a rawer picture.
He said he believed “they were never going to film me as Marv” and that Hughes’s cold handshake signaled the decision before he was formally told. Columbus acknowledged on the podcast that they never collaborated again, adding, “I thought at the time, maybe.” Entertainment Weekly reached out to a representative for Roebuck for comment.
The contrast underscores a recurring tension in Hollywood lore: the director’s memory of a merciful exit versus the actor’s memory of a broken promise. Roebuck’s career continued — he later appeared in The Fugitive, Lost, and Glee — but the Home Alone chapter remained an open wound.
Columbus went on to direct Mrs. Doubtfire and the first two Harry Potter films; Roebuck never received the promised part.