Eighth Circuit to Hear Challenge to South Dakota Top 5 Donor Law

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit will hear oral arguments Wednesday at CST on November 18 in Courtroom 5A of the Federal Court Building in St.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit will hear oral arguments Wednesday in Students for Life Action v. Jackley, a challenge to a South Dakota law that requires nonprofit organizations to identify their top five donors in certain political communications.

Liberty Justice Center, representing Students for Life Action, is asking the court to strike down the law. The organization argues the disclosure requirement violates the First Amendment rights to free speech and free association.

Liberty Justice Center contends the government cannot force nonprofits to convey its preferred message or expose their supporters to public scrutiny as a condition of engaging in political advocacy, according to a media alert from the organization.

Arguments are scheduled for 9 a.m. CST on November 18 in Courtroom 5A of the Federal Court Building in St. Paul, Minnesota. Members of the public may listen to live audio by dialing 1-571-353-2301 with access code 044556657. The court will post MP3 recordings on its website after the day’s arguments are completed.

Eighth circuit arguments

The case stems from a federal lawsuit filed June 5, 2023, on behalf of Students for Life Action, a nonprofit with a South Dakota chapter that advocates for candidates, policy changes and legal action supporting its pro-life mission. The statute compels nonprofits that engage in covered communications regarding public officials, candidates or political parties to publicly name their five largest donors.

Liberty Justice Center argues the mandate forces organizations to incorporate government-compelled speech into their messages and publicly links donors with communications they may not have helped create or funded for that purpose. Students for Life Action is concerned that mandatory public disclosure will expose its supporters to harassment and retaliation, discourage donations and undermine its ability to carry out its mission.