Cignetti Points to Mistakes in Indiana’s Overtime Defeat to Washington

On November 21, 2026, sixth-ranked Indiana suffered a 27-24 overtime defeat against Washington in Seattle, dealing a severe blow to the team’s College Football Playoff hopes.

Missed Opportunities and Special Teams Struggles

Head coach Curt Cignetti pointed to self-inflicted mistakes and special teams miscues as decisive factors in the game.

“In the second half, fought and clawed,” Cignetti said postgame. “But [Washington] made one more play, we didn’t. That’s that … I give the guys a lot of credit for the way they competed.”

“Too many missed opportunities again,” Cignetti said.

“Congrats to Washington, they made more plays than we did. That’s football man, tough one to swallow,” Cignetti said.

Kicking struggles plagued Indiana throughout the afternoon. Nicolas Radicic had a 46-yard field goal blocked in the third quarter, prompting Cignetti to turn to Paddy McAteer, who converted a 34-yard attempt.

However, McAteer missed a 37-yard attempt in overtime that would have extended the game. Radicic stands at 13 of 19 on field-goal tries this season.

“How do you go back to [Radicic], when [McAteer] drilled a 60-yarder to win a game and drilled the one opportunity he had [earlier in the game]?” Cignetti said.

“We’ve missed too many field goals this year, and the other guy had made them,” Cignetti said. “That was the plan going in. We gave (McAteer) an opportunity, and he missed the field goal.”

Photo: abcnews.com

McAteer’s overtime attempt appeared to be partially blocked.

Quarterback Changes and Mounting Injuries

Indiana also shuffled its lineup under center. After starting Grant Wilson for the second consecutive game, Cignetti replaced him with Josh Hoover in the third quarter.

Curt Cignetti reacts to IU football's overtime loss at Washington — Inside the Hall

“I went in fully hoping and believing that Grant would do well and make it through the whole game,” Cignetti said. “We just got a little shaky there, something I sensed.”

Wilson finished 8-for-16 for 119 yards and a touchdown, while Hoover completed 7-of-13 passes for 121 yards and a score.

Washington BEATS Indiana in OT, 27-24: Huskies shake up the Big Ten by defeating Curt Cignetti, IU — On3

The quarterback switch leaves the position uncertain ahead of the regular-season finale. Cignetti stated he had not thought that far ahead when asked if Hoover would start next week.

“I haven’t thought that far ahead,” Cignetti said.

Curt Cignetti laments IU football's wasted opportunities in overtime loss at Washington — IndyStarTV: Hoosiers

Compounding the offensive struggles, injuries piled up along the offensive line. The team lost center Bray Lynch and right tackle Adedamola Ajani during the contest, forcing Austin Leibfried to move to center alongside reserves Baylor Wilkin and Sam Simpson.

Indiana entered the game without starting right guard Joe Brunner. Ajani eventually returned, but the Hoosiers were forced to shuffle the offensive line extensively.

Washington capitalized on the Hoosiers’ defensive wear, rushing for 189 yards, including an 88-yard performance by quarterback Demond Williams Jr. that featured a 65-yard touchdown run.

Photo: sports.yahoo.com

“Two things was don’t let the quarterback scramble in the pocket and don’t let them throw it behind us,” Cignetti said. “But I thought we came back and played better defensively in the second half.”

“The injuries did pile up,” Cignetti said. “At one point we had three offensive linemen out.”

Indiana vs. Washington Overtime Ending — Bleacher Report and B/R CFB

The Road Ahead for the Hoosiers

With the regular-season finale against Purdue approaching, Indiana must regroup to secure its postseason position. Whether Hoover or Wilson will lead the offense next week remains undetermined.

“I don’t really know right now, to be honest with you,” Indiana wide receiver Charlie Becker said. “We have a lot of grit on this team.”