Colorado water managers walked back a September commitment to launch a statewide conservation program for 2027 after federal officials declined to guarantee that saved water would stay in Lake Powell rather than flow downstream to California, Arizona and Nevada.
The Colorado Water Conservation Board reversed course at its regular meeting Wednesday, deciding that without a written assurance of “operational neutrality” from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, the state could not ask farmers and ranchers to enroll in time for the coming irrigation season, Aspen Journalism reported. Utah and Wyoming are proceeding with agricultural conservation programs in their own states.
The decision leaves Colorado contributing little water next year to an Upper Basin effort backed by $100 million in federal funding designed to prop up Powell’s elevations. Becky Mitchell, Colorado’s representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission, framed the stakes bluntly at the meeting: the state wants to tell water users, “You’re not just saving so that others can overuse.”
“We are very late in the year at this point,” said Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief with the CWCB. “It would be really challenging, I think, for a lot of agricultural water users to consider enrolling at this point without this certainty.”
— Amy Ostdiek, CWCB interstate section chief, speaking at the board meeting Wednesday
The mechanics of the standoff
Under the proposed “near-term contribution program,” the state would pay water users — primarily Western Slope irrigators — to temporarily cut back, storing the conserved water in Powell, Flaming Gorge, Blue Mesa or Navajo reservoirs. But Colorado’s approval in September was explicitly conditioned on Reclamation agreeing that any saved water would be “operationally neutral,” meaning it would not factor into the calculus that determines annual releases to the Lower Basin.
Reclamation has not provided that guarantee. In a Nov. 10 letter to Upper Basin officials, Assistant Secretary for Water and Science Andrea Travnicek wrote that operational neutrality would require a broader seven-state conversation. “There is currently no water within the Colorado River Basin that is considered operationally neutral,” the letter says. “Until such agreements are made, reservoir operations will continue to be based upon the physical elevations.”
That formulation effectively means every acre-foot Colorado saves simply raises Powell’s surface elevation, which under current operating rules triggers larger releases to Lake Mead and the Lower Basin. Colorado officials argue that dynamic traps the system in a cycle of overuse, preventing the Upper Basin from rebuilding storage depleted by two decades of drought and rising demand.
Agriculture left on the sidelines
By excluding agricultural users, the program loses its primary source of water. In the federally funded System Conservation Pilot Program that ran in 2023 and 2024, the Upper Basin saved roughly 101,000 acre-feet at a cost of $45 million. Colorado’s share was about 24,300 acre-feet — a fraction of Powell’s capacity — and all of it came from Western Slope agriculture, the sources show.
Front Range water providers have expressed interest in participating, but the volume available from municipal and industrial conservation is far smaller. The board will consider a limited, non-agricultural program at its January meeting.
“Look, we’re happy to participate and help Reclamation protect its facilities at Glen Canyon,” Andy Mueller, general manager of the Colorado River Water Conservation District, told Aspen Journalism. “We’re happy to set up a pool to make sure we stay in compliance with our obligations under the compact. But no one wants to dry up productive agricultural ground or economic activity and industry or the cities in our state in order to just send water down to fill swimming pools in Scottsdale.”
— Andy Mueller, Colorado River Water Conservation District general manager, told Aspen Journalism
States sue over federal river operating plan
The impasse reflects a deeper fracture in river governance. The seven basin states failed to agree on long-term operating guidelines after years of negotiation, prompting the federal government to impose a two-year operating plan in August that mandates 1.25 million acre-feet of Lower Basin cuts and sets Powell releases between 6 million and 7 million acre-feet annually. Nevada and Arizona have since sued the Department of the Interior over that plan.
At Wednesday’s meeting, the CWCB voted to increase Colorado’s litigation fund to $10 million from $6 million, allocating $4 million specifically to the Colorado River Basin — the largest single-basin allocation in the state.
Mueller described the governance dysfunction bluntly: “I would hope that our states find a way to knock those discussions loose so that we can actually have meaningful conversations about this and some other key elements of a potential governance framework.”
Hydrology dwarfs conservation
State officials also emphasized that nature remains the dominant variable. Ostdiek said that Powell gained roughly 1.3 million acre-feet over the previous six weeks from fall storms — equivalent to 26 years of savings under the pilot program. “I think it provides a reminder that the system is largely driven by hydrology,” she said.
Founded by the legislature in 1937 as a division of the Department of Natural Resources, the Colorado Water Conservation Board convened its first twelve directors on July 13 of that year. Over the decades its portfolio expanded from defending compact entitlements and building water projects to include instream flow rights, floodplain mapping and drought planning, culminating in the 2015 Colorado Water Plan ordered by the governor.
Today the fifteen-member board, supported by more than 40 staff across six program areas, also houses the Interstate and Federal section whose chief, Amy Ostdiek, warned the board this week that enrolling agricultural users for 2027 is impractical without federal certainty.
Reclamation says it remains committed to working with Upper Basin states on an agreement to account for, verify and credit conserved water, and to establish storage and release rules for a conservation pool.
But with the 2027 irrigation season approaching and no written guarantee in hand, Colorado has effectively sat out the next round — leaving the question of whether the Upper Basin can ever bank water for itself, rather than for the Lower Basin, unresolved.