Colts Risers and Fallers After Week 9 Loss to Cowboys

The Indianapolis Colts dropped to a 2-7 record on Sunday, suffering their fifth consecutive loss in a 27-23 defeat against the Dallas Cowboys at Lucas Oil Stadium.

While the team’s collective trajectory remains difficult, the afternoon provided a stark contrast between established veterans struggling to find their footing and a rookie class beginning to demand a larger share of the spotlight.

The Rising Impact of the Rookie Class

Defensive end Caden Curry is rapidly moving from a depth piece to a reliable contributor. Against Dallas, Curry recorded his first professional sack and recovered a fumble, marking the first time a Colts rookie has achieved that specific stat line in a single game since Josh Mallard in 2002. His consistent presence around the football has become a bright spot for a defense currently undergoing a significant personnel transition.

The Colts already turned down a 2027 second-round draft pick plus an additional pick for RB Jonathan Taylor, making clear they’d want a premium to trade the face of the franchise. All the trade updates you can handle in The Sweep Insider Notebook: https://t.co/2eiMVV6AJ1 pic.twitter.com/FDIrQ5k9gc

— Post by @TomPelissero on X

Fellow rookie defensive end Jaylahn Tuimoloau matched that intensity, logging his first career sack alongside four pressures. After a slow start to his professional career, Tuimoloau’s integration into the defensive line rotation is showing the dividends of his second-round draft pedigree. His recent performance suggests that the coaching staff may lean more heavily on younger defenders as the season enters its final stretch.

Adam Schefter on Colts asking price for WR Josh Downs: "Josh Downs, the Colts have told teams they're looking for third round value. Nobody's willing to do that right now. And I think if you ask for third round value, you look at last year. Last year, Rashid Shaheed went for a…”

— Post by @Steelersdepot on X

The youth movement extended to the backfield, where running back Seth McGowan rushed for 45 yards on just six attempts. His 7.5 yards-per-carry average was highlighted by a 36-yard burst—the longest rushing play of the day for Indianapolis—and his first career touchdown. With the NFL trade deadline looming this Tuesday, McGowan’s efficiency offers the organization a potential pathway forward if they choose to move on from veteran starters.

Linebacker CJ Allen is similarly carving out a role, securing double-digit tackle numbers for the second straight week. Stepping into his first significant starting opportunity, Allen has displayed the kind of situational awareness often lacking in younger players. His ability to anchor the defense while dealing with injuries across the roster has made him a vital, if unexpected, building block for the remainder of the 2026 campaign.

Veteran Struggles and Trade Deadline Pressures

While the newcomers gained ground, key veterans faced a difficult afternoon that may influence the front office’s decision-making before the trade deadline. Running back Jonathan Taylor finished with 46 yards on 13 carries, a 3.5-yard average that fell short of the production required to sustain the Colts’ offense. A late-game fumble further complicated his performance, casting a shadow over his status with the team as the deadline approaches.

Colts Risers and Fallers After Week 9 Loss to Cowboys

The offensive line, usually a point of stability, also faltered. Left tackle Bernhard Raimann, who commands a $100-million valuation, was penalized three times during the loss. One illegal formation call wiped out a critical third-down completion to Deion Burks, while a fourth-quarter holding penalty stalled a drive that could have changed the game’s outcome. These uncharacteristic errors forced the offense into disadvantageous down-and-distance situations throughout the second half.

Wide receiver Josh Downs also struggled to generate momentum, catching three of his six targets for 24 yards. Two dropped passes, including a high-stakes miss on third down late in the game, forced the Colts to settle for a field goal rather than extending a drive.

This drop in production occurs at a precarious time for Downs, whose own trade-rumor cycle has added an extra layer of uncertainty to his future in Indianapolis.

The stakes for the organization are clear. As the team sits at 2-7, the focus is shifting from immediate contention to the long-term viability of its roster. The personnel decisions made in the coming 48 hours will likely determine whether the team prioritizes the veterans who have defined the last few seasons or the rookies who are currently providing the only consistent spark on the field.

Worth a look