Columbia rejected a settlement offer that would require firing Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief of Operations Anthony Holloway, calling the demand “egregious” in a Facebook post responding to a filing by the Irmo Fire District.
The offer, filed Nov. 16 in Richland County Common Pleas Court, also seeks about $40,296 in legal fees and costs, published apologies from the two officials and dismissal of all claims against the district, according to The State. The city said it disagrees with the allegations made by other lawyers in the case and looks forward to representing Columbia firefighters “before a neutral and detached jury.”
The collapse that started the case
James Michael Muller, 25, died after an apartment building collapsed during a May 2023 fire at the Tropical Ridge complex in Columbia. Three other Irmo firefighters trapped in the collapse survived. His wife, Emma Elizabeth Muller, sued the city and Richland County; Columbia brought Irmo Fire District into the litigation as a third-party defendant.

What the NIOSH report found
A National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health report cited communication failures, problems tracking firefighters and insufficient understanding of the building’s structural risks. The Irmo Fire District’s offer says it is not an admission of liability and gives the recipients 20 days to accept.
Positions laid bare
The city’s statement frames the demand as an attack on “two long-standing dedicated public servants.” The district’s filing frames the offer as a path to resolve its own exposure without admitting fault. The two characterizations share almost no common ground.
“The City of Columbia does not comment on pending litigation,” the city said in a Facebook post. “However, the calling for resignation of two long-standing dedicated public servants is egregious.”
Attorneys for the Irmo Fire District wrote in the Nov. 16 filing that the offer “is not an admission of liability” and provides a 20-day window for acceptance.
20-day offer clock runs from Nov. 16 filing
The 20-day clock on the offer runs from the Nov. 16 filing. If the city does not accept, the case proceeds toward trial with Columbia defending its chiefs and the district pressing its third-party claims.