“We will not accept an outcome that undermines our security and threatens our future,” said Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner, climate envoy for the Marshall Islands, as COP31 talks in Antalya collapsed without a deal on Sunday, RNZ reported.
After running 44 hours past their Friday deadline, the United Nations climate summit ended in disarray when the European Union, Pacific island nations, Panama, and African states rejected a final draft that omitted any mention of fossil fuels, according to Al Jazeera and the BBC. The last time UN climate talks failed to produce an adopted agreement was in Copenhagen in 2009, Al Jazeera noted.
"Little hands, big change." As the #COP31 U. N. climate talks wrap up in Turkey, hear 8-year-old Kenyan activist Marren Akeyo's message to world leaders. "I have a question for all the big people here today: You have big offices, big cars, big meetings, and sometimes very big… pic.twitter.com/mIdoYZWEez”
Fossil fuel language stripped from text
Successive drafts removed references to a transition away from coal, oil, and gas that had been agreed at COP28 in Dubai in 2023, The Guardian and DW.com reported. Saudi Arabia led opposition to the wording, while the EU and a coalition of about 130 countries insisted on its inclusion, The Guardian said. The final Antalya Accords draft released early Sunday instead included an oblique reference to the 2023 agreement and language promoting carbon capture and storage, which critics called a loophole for continued fossil fuel use, according to Stuff and 350.org.
“It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover decision that does not even mention fossil fuels and we simply will not put up with it,” said Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama’s minister for the environment, per Source 7. The country’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, said Panama would “not lend its name” to “complacent or ineffective language” in the final pact, DW.com reported.
“We cannot be announcing to the world that we are now getting to 1.5 increase in the temperature and do business like nothing was happening,” said France’s Minister of Ecological Transition Monique Barbut, per Source 7. Although one lead negotiator said he sympathised: “How can you have a climate agreement with no mention of the cause,” per Source 7.
Adaptation finance commitments also dropped
Earlier text proposing a tripling of adaptation funding to $120 billion annually by 2035 was removed from the final draft, the BBC reported. Developing countries estimated annual adaptation needs at $305 billion through 2035, DW.com said. “We did not come here to beg we came here to claim what is rightfully ours,” said Zanetor Agyeman Rawlings, Ghana’s environment minister and chair of the African Group of negotiators.
“This is insufficient for a climate conference that already decided several years ago to phase out fossil fuels and that presents itself as a conference focused on implementation,” he said in a statement, DW.com reported.
A climate deal that leaves out fossil fuels is like a plan to quit smoking that never mentions cigarettes. Yet – once again – today’s revised #COP31 draft drops every mention of fossil fuels, just as last year’s final text did. Read more:https://t.co/ddfdg5b7Hd pic.twitter.com/4nMO0GxhHB
Fossil fuel language removed from successive drafts
The first draft of the agreed outcome contained a resolution on phasing out fossil fuels, but it was excised from a revised draft published on Thursday, The Guardian reported. Saudi Arabia and its allies prevented further progress on putting the 2023 Dubai agreement into action, the same source said.
Adaptation finance targets dropped and 1.5°C overshoot acknowledged
Jan Kowalzig of Oxfam Germany noted the second draft had called for further discussions on tripling finance and acknowledged the gap between flows and needs, DW.com added.
David Waskow, director of the World Resources Institute’s International Climate Initiative, said it is critically important for this COP to recognize that the world is on the way to overshooting 1.5 degrees, DW.com reported. He called it the first COP that will likely do so, according to the same source.
First COP to acknowledge 1.5C overshoot
The draft would have been the first UN climate agreement to acknowledge that global warming is on course to exceed the 1.5°C Paris Agreement target, Al Jazeera and the BBC reported.
A New Zealand climate scientist told RNZ the summit had “backslid” on major issues and risked being seen as “a flop.” “Bottom line is I think people are losing faith in the process,” the scientist said, “but I think the majority would be very loathe to leave it, because it’s all we’ve got at the moment.”
At COP31 in Antalya, Marshall Islands climate envoy Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner declared the nation would not accept an outcome that undermines its security and threatens its future, RNZ reported. The Republic of the Marshall Islands is one of only four atoll-based nations globally, with 98.47% of its territory consisting of lagoon waters — the largest proportion of water to land of any sovereign state — leaving its population acutely exposed to rising seas.
I'm deeply disappointed that #COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome. I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands. But this setback does not change the facts. There may be no… pic.twitter.com/SBMZPpfU5l
COP31 President Murat Kurum told delegates “it is clear that these decisions have not been adopted,” Al Jazeera reported. Negotiators now face an uncertain path toward the next summit, with the IPCC’s next assessment reports due for a 2028 global stocktake, the NZ Herald noted.
More on Saudi Arabia
The dramatic impacts of the climate crisis can be felt everywhere. I have just witnessed it again here at the rice terraces in Banaue, Philippines. The only effective response is urgent #ClimateAction: ending our addiction to fossil fuels, transitioning to renewables &… pic.twitter.com/lLe5VyJJjK
- Fifteen Years After Comptroller Report, Poland Remains Israel’s Near-Exclusive Holocaust Trip Destination
- Alexandra Daddario Downplays Rumors of Bond Role Opposite Pattinson
- COP29 in Antalya Ends Without Agreement Over Fossil Fuel Language (world-today-news.com)
- Theresa May warns Andy Burnham to move on from Brexit after EU talks (newsarchyuk.com)