Delaware County Prosecutor Rules Muncie Officer Justified in Standoff Shooting

March 31 brought a three-hour standoff to a quiet west-side Muncie street, and eight months later a single finding: the officer who fired was legally justified.

Delaware County Prosecutor Eric Hoffman closed the investigation Thursday, ruling that the shooting of 76-year-old Charles Zearbaugh met Indiana’s standard for self-defense and defense of others. “The facts demonstrate conclusively and without a doubt,” Hoffman wrote, that the officer acted in self-defense and in defense of others. “His actions were objectively and subjectively reasonable,” he added after reviewing the Indiana State Police investigation, WTHR reported.

The decision rests on a mountain of evidence: a nearly 400-page ISP report, footage from more than 80 body cameras, and over 500 photographs. Hoffman said video, officer statements, and physical evidence all corroborated the officer’s account that Zearbaugh pointed a gun toward officers as they broke a back window to deploy a chemical agent.

“His actions were completely and legally justified,” Hoffman wrote. No criminal charges will be filed.

Officers arrived at the 300 block of South Ivy Wood Drive for a welfare check after a neighbor reported Zearbaugh yelling, throwing objects, and acting erratically. When the first officer approached, prosecutors said Zearbaugh opened the door and pointed a gun at him, prompting an immediate retreat and a call for backup.

Delaware County Prosecutor Rules Muncie Officer Justified in Standoff Shooting
Photo: yahoo.com

For more than three hours, negotiators called, texted, and used a public-address system trying to coax Zearbaugh outside. He refused. During the standoff, police obtained a court-authorized warrant to take him into custody for a psychological and medical evaluation and to seize any firearms.

Officers breached the front door, moved to the rear of the home, and attempted to deploy a chemical agent. As they broke a back window, an officer saw Zearbaugh inside a room pointing a gun toward them and fired his rifle.

Zearbaugh was transported to IU Health Ball Memorial Hospital, where he died from multiple gunshot wounds, according to the autopsy cited by the prosecutor.

Muncie, about 50 miles northeast of Indianapolis, is the Delaware County seat and home to Ball State University. Its population was 65,195 in the 2020 census, down from 70,085 in 2010.

The city grew from a Lenape settlement called Munsee Town in the 1790s, was platted as Muncietown in 1827, and shortened its name to Muncie in 1845. It became a manufacturing hub after the Indiana gas boom of the 1880s attracted the Ball Brothers Glass Manufacturing Company, which began production there in 1888.

The investigation is closed. The officer’s name has not been released.