Delaware Regulators Reject ChristianaCare Downstate Micro-Hospital Expansions

Delaware hospital regulators rejected ChristianaCare’s plan to build two micro-hospitals downstate on Tuesday, handing the Wilmington-based system a decisive defeat in its push to expand below the Chesapeake & Delaware Canal.

The Delaware Health Resources Board voted 8-1 to deny the Georgetown application. The Camden application was also denied. The dual denial blocks more than $123 million in planned investment and ends, for now, a months-long feud that redrew the competitive map of Delaware health care.

“We are extremely disappointed with the board’s decision,” ChristianaCare CEO Jenn Schwartz said in a statement after the vote. “Families in Kent and Sussex counties have asked for more services closer to their homes, and ChristianaCare’s proposals worked to address gaps in care.”

Bayhealth CEO Terry Murphy, whose Dover-based system led the opposition alongside Beebe Healthcare and TidalHealth, called the outcome a win for affordability. “We believe improving healthcare access requires balancing access, quality and affordability,” Murphy said. “Bayhealth welcomes competition and supports expanding outpatient services, but we do not believe adding small hospitals is the best approach for our communities.”

The proposed campus would have been located off of Route 113 near Ennis St. which is also across from DelTech
Photo: wdel.com

The numbers that unraveled the pitch

Board members spent the meeting pressing ChristianaCare on data discrepancies between its initial application and the presentation delivered Tuesday.

The most damaging exchange came when John Hundley, chief operating officer at Westside Family Healthcare, zeroed in on a projection he read as 3.6 million annual emergency visits for the Camden site — a figure that would imply roughly 18 visits per year for every man, woman and child in a county of fewer than 200,000 residents.

ChristianaCare representatives said the figure was not correct and had not been intended that way. But the damage was done. “I’m kind of a numbers guy, and when they don’t add up, it’s like pulling the one straw and everything kind of falls apart,” Hundley said, explaining his vote.

Board members also questioned whether the two campuses were truly inseparable. ChristianaCare officials had told the board they would proceed only if both were approved, a linkage that several members said made it impossible to evaluate the projects on their individual merits.

Delaware board rejects ChristianaCare's proposed micro-hospitals in Georgetown and Camden — CoastTV

What the campuses would have delivered

The Georgetown campus, projected at $65.1 million and 42,000 square feet, would have risen near Route 113 and Ennis Street across from Delaware Technical Community College. Plans called for eight emergency department beds, eight inpatient beds, primary care, specialty care and behavioral health services, with a target opening in early 2029, WDEL reported.

The Camden campus, a $58.1 million facility on U.S. Route 13 about a mile from the Walmart, was similarly scoped. ChristianaCare said the two sites would create 83 new jobs and expand emergency access in a region the federal government has designated a Medically Underserved Area.

A region remapped by retirees

Sussex County’s population jumped from 237,000 in 2022 to a projected 361,000 by 2050, driven largely by retirees who require more frequent and complex care. That growth has turned the once-sleepy downstate market into a contested frontier. For decades, ChristianaCare held New Castle County, Bayhealth held Kent, and Beebe Healthcare held coastal Sussex. TidalHealth, based in Salisbury, Maryland, has recently pushed north into western Sussex.

All three downstate systems have broken ground on their own expansions in Lewes, Milton and Millsboro in recent years. ChristianaCare’s entry would have been the first time an upstate giant planted full-service emergency beds in their territory.

The licensing gap no one has filled

Opponents argued that Delaware law lacks a licensing category for “micro-hospitals,” creating regulatory ambiguity. TidalHealth questioned whether the proposed facilities met the state’s legal definition of a hospital. Beebe argued they did not meet requirements for a general hospital.

Bayhealth pointed to the involvement of Emerus Holdings, a for-profit company that would have owned and operated the campuses under a partnership with the nonprofit ChristianaCare — a structure that drew new scrutiny after legislation signed this summer aimed at curbing for-profit influence in nonprofit health care.

Dr. Vincent Lobo, a board member, said he opposed the Georgetown project because existing facilities already offer the services ChristianaCare proposed. He also warned the location could create access obstacles for emergency patients.

Residents caught in the middle

Not everyone in the room saw the proposals as a threat. “There’s a lack of medical attention because of so many people in the area,” Joanne Wilkins, a Sussex County resident, told WDEL. She said her primary care doctor is leaving, leaving her scrambling to find a replacement. Linda Robison described similar struggles: “It’s hard. You know, my medical doctor, I usually have to make an appointment for a checkup.”

ChristianaCare said it will “carefully review the decision and evaluate our options.” A motion by board member Steve Biener to table the Camden vote and give the system time to address the board’s questions failed for lack of a second.

The Health Resources Board has denied similar downstate projects before — rejecting a Beebe freestanding ER in Georgetown in 2019 and prompting Bayhealth to withdraw its own Milton ER plan rather than face a likely denial.

ChristianaCare traces its roots to 1888, when Delaware Hospital opened in Wilmington; the system took shape through a 1965 merger with Memorial Hospital and Wilmington General Hospital that created Wilmington Medical Center, and the 1985 opening of Christiana Hospital in Newark, which remains the state’s only adult Level I trauma center.

Headquartered in Wilmington, the private, non-profit network now employs more than 10,000 people, operates three hospitals across Delaware and Maryland, and in 2023 paid $47.7 million to settle a federal False Claims Act case.

For now, the geographic monopolies hold. The retirees keep arriving. And the next move belongs to ChristianaCare.