A proposed amendment to the New York Constitution would make the state the twelfth to enshrine an explicit right to privacy, closing a gap that leaves intimate medical decisions and sensitive digital records vulnerable to government demands.
The push comes after the Trump administration demanded a dossier from NYU Langone in May identifying patients who received gender-affirming care as minors, including their medical records. The administration has labeled that care “chemical and surgical mutilation.”
A federal judge blocked the disclosure, and the Second Circuit refused to lift the stay, but the episode exposed a structural weakness: exercising a statutory right created a paper trail that became the threat itself.
“For them, exercising a right created a file that became the threat itself,” wrote Jared M. Trujillo, an associate professor at CUNY School of Law and founding director of the CUNY Law State Policy Lab, in the analysis published Thursday by State Court Report.
Eleven state constitutions already contain freestanding privacy guarantees. New Hampshire was the most recent to adopt one, in 2018, with roughly 81 percent of voters in favor. New York’s amendment must pass two consecutive legislative sessions before going to voters, where a simple majority would ratify it. The earliest it could appear on the ballot is 2029.
Borrowing the Strongest Models
The proposal is a deliberate composite. Its opening sentence — “the right of the people to privacy shall not be infringed” — tracks the freestanding guarantees in Alaska and Hawaii. The second sentence draws from Washington’s private-affairs jurisprudence, requiring courts to weigh both the scope of information available to the government and the degree of intrusion.
That design signals to New York courts that they should look to those states’ decisions when interpreting the new protections. Washington courts, for instance, have rejected the federal third-party doctrine and protected bank records, text messages, hotel records, and cell-phone data as private affairs. Hawaii’s supreme court treats medical records as constitutionally protected and has barred forced disclosure of even de-identified patient records without a compelling state interest.
Statutory Shields Are Not Enough
New York currently relies on shield laws that limit state cooperation with out-of-state investigations into legally protected reproductive and gender-affirming care. But statutes can be repealed or narrowed with a change in legislative majorities. A constitutional right is structurally harder to dislodge.
New York courts have already interpreted the state’s search-and-seizure clause more broadly than the federal Fourth Amendment. Yet those protections only trigger when government conduct amounts to a search or seizure. Privacy harms can begin earlier — through collection, retention, or compelled disclosure of sensitive information — even when no traditional “search” occurs. An explicit privacy right gives courts a framework to confront that injury directly.
The Federal Floor Has Crumbled
Federal privacy doctrine once protected the right to direct a child’s upbringing, refuse medical treatment, marry, use contraception, and — for nearly half a century — obtain an abortion. The Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization overturned the last of those. Justice Clarence Thomas used the occasion to urge reconsideration of several other privacy precedents.
Informational privacy is even less settled federally. In every case where the question arose, the government prevailed. Circuits remain divided, with some expressing doubt the Constitution protects it at all.
That gap is dangerous in a world where communications we experience as private routinely pass through intermediaries. Under the traditional third-party doctrine, information shared with companies like Meta or Google may lose constitutional protection simply because a third party holds it.
The Supreme Court took a step this summer in Chatrie v. United States, holding that obtaining a person’s Google location history constitutes a search.
When Privacy and Equality Work Together
New York’s proposed amendment would operate alongside the state Equal Rights Amendment, which voters ratified in 2024.
Alaska and California show how powerful that combination can be. Alaska’s privacy amendment, coupled with its equality guarantee, produced an affirmative right: its supreme court recognized reproductive choice as a fundamental privacy right in 1997 and held four years later that equal protection barred the state from funding medically necessary pregnancy care through Medicaid while excluding medically necessary abortions. California’s high court reached a similar result.
In New York, privacy would protect the decision and the information itself; equality would guard against discriminatory burdens on exercising the underlying right.
Surveillance Infrastructure That Outlives Administrations
The NYPD runs the nation’s largest urban public-safety data collection system, the Domain Awareness System, built with Microsoft. It ingests feeds from public and private cameras, license-plate readers, and police databases — technology that has been exported to other jurisdictions.
Across the state, facial recognition, license-plate readers, building-access systems, and location data build detailed dossiers, and artificial intelligence makes it easier to exploit that data.
Those technologies expose marginalized New Yorkers most. Approximately 99 percent of those on the NYPD’s gang database are Latino or Black boys or men, many placed there because they live in the same low-income neighborhoods as others on the list.
Public housing tenants are suing over an arrangement giving police real-time access to housing authority camera feeds through infrastructure tied to a free internet program, set to expand to nearly 20,000 cameras. Landlords, meanwhile, use smart-access systems that record when and how tenants enter their buildings, prompting the city to regulate that data and consider further restrictions on residential facial recognition.
A National Movement
Delaware’s privacy amendment has cleared a legislative committee, while lawmakers in Tennessee and Wisconsin introduced similar measures this year.
CUNY School of Law was founded in 1983 as the city’s only publicly funded law school with a dual mission to train public interest lawyers and diversify the legal profession. Its curriculum integrates clinical teaching with traditional studies and emphasizes civil rights law and indigent defense.
The school gained accreditation under its second dean, W. Haywood Burns, the first African American dean of a New York law school, and is currently ranked fourth nationally for clinical education.
Whether it survives a second session and a statewide vote remains an open question.