Columbia, Missouri, has long been a pit stop for Mizzou journalism alumni chasing a slice of Shakespeare’s Pizza, but a new guide from American Weekender argues the college town’s dining scene has matured well beyond that single nostalgia trip.
Editors Amy Cavanaugh and Kenney Marlatt spent the summer mapping breakfast, lunch, dinner and drinks across the city, positioning Columbia alongside peers like Oxford, Miss., and Ann Arbor, Mich., in their “American Weekender” Field Guide series.
The downtown Shakespeare’s outpost, rebuilt in 2016 steps from the Missouri School of Journalism, remains the gravitational center for students and visitors alike. Medium-thick crust, craggy edges and a heavy hand with oregano define the pie — a style Cavanaugh describes as “simple until it’s your nostalgia hit, and then it’s your favorite anywhere.”
The shop pours brown ale from Bur Oak Brewing Company and Logboat Lite Lager from Logboat Brewing Company, two local labels that have expanded distribution statewide since the guide’s original reporting.
“Grads of the journalism program all seem to love one thing: Shakespeare’s Pizza.”
Cavanaugh and Marlatt wrote in the Field Guide, noting the downtown location sits “mere feet from the J-School.”

Beyond the institution, the guide flags a biscuit-focused breakfast, a new-wave sandwich shop and a cocktail bar the editors call “truly great,” though the Field Guide reserves specific names and addresses for paid subscribers. The pair also highlight a "new-school slice favorite," showing a generational shift in the town’s pizza conversation that mirrors trends in larger Midwestern metros.
Columbia’s inclusion in the series — the 33rd Field Guide published by American Weekender — reflects a broader editorial bet on secondary cities with dense university populations. The latest guide before this one covered Gulf Shores and Orange Beach, Ala., complete with a three-day seafood itinerary. Subscribers receive a searchable Google map and archive access; individual guides are also sold à la carte.
Columbia, Missouri, was founded in 1821 by Kentucky pioneers as the Boone County seat after bedrock made well-digging impossible at the nearby village of Smithton. The town secured the state university in 1839 by raising three times more money than any competitor and donating the land that became Francis Quadrangle, establishing education as a pillar alongside medicine and insurance.
Its infrastructure survived the Civil War largely untouched despite major battles at Boonville and Centralia nearby, and the city later became a crossroads when U.S. Routes 63 and 40 — now Interstate 70 — were routed through it.
The Weekend Reading list accompanying the Columbia drop points readers toward a Chicago bar debut, a roster of Midwest boutique hotels in historic buildings and a Jackson Hole, Wyo., food-and-activity itinerary — each curated with the same subscriber-gated model.