Former Texas Lab CEO Sentenced to Prison for Falsifying Wastewater Tests to Conceal Pollution

A former Texas laboratory CEO was sentenced on November 17 to 12 months in federal prison and fined $250,000 for orchestrating a scheme that concealed illegal pollution levels from regulators for nearly three years, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Texas announced.

Derek McCoy, 52, of The Woodlands, pleaded guilty June 11 to falsifying or aiding and abetting the falsification of data required under the Clean Water Act. McCoy served as CEO and part-owner of North Water District Laboratory Services in Conroe, and oversaw the testing of wastewater from local treatment facilities.

From February 2021 through February 2024, he and others altered results for E. coli, ammonia and phosphorus to make it appear the plants were complying with state-issued discharge permits, according to federal prosecutors. Those doctored reports were then submitted to the Environmental Protection Agency and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.

“This case is about the integrity of the data that regulators and the public rely on to know whether their water is safe,” said Assistant U.S. Attorney Steven Schammel, who prosecuted the case alongside Liesel Roscher and Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Nathan Stopper.

The scheme relied on electronic methods that allowed results to be changed without leaving the usual audit trail, the Wharton Post reported, citing federal case records.

Dana Higginbotham, 56, of Spring, identified in court records as a laboratory official, and John Montgomery, 60, of Llano, described as a compliance coordinator working with wastewater facilities, both admitted their roles. The Justice Department’s November sentencing release spells Higginbotham’s first name “Dana”; earlier case materials used “Deena.” The November announcement did not provide sentencing outcomes for the other two defendants.

Senior U.S. District Judge David Hittner ordered McCoy to serve one year of supervised release following his prison term. McCoy was permitted to remain on bond and voluntarily surrender to a Federal Bureau of Prisons facility to be determined in the near future.

The investigation was conducted by the EPA Criminal Investigation Division, the EPA Office of Inspector General, and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality – Environmental Crimes Unit through the Texas Environmental Enforcement Task Force.