Four Alaska House Seats Flip; 35-Year GOP Run in Homer Ends

Independent Brent Johnson unseated incumbent Sarah Vance by about 60 votes, ending a 35-year GOP run in Homer.

State election officials finished counting and tabulated ranked-choice results at a news conference in Juneau Wednesday night, locking in a Legislature that will look markedly different when it gavels in next year.

Neither chamber flipped — Democrats and their allies keep the House and a bipartisan coalition holds the Senate — but fourteen races came down to the final tabulation, and four House seats flipped to candidates aligned with the Democrat-heavy coalition. Five Republican incumbents lost. Alaska Public Media reported the details as Eric Stone broke them down with host Casey Grove on Alaska News Nightly.

The most striking turnover came on the southern Kenai Peninsula, where Homer and the surrounding area had sent a Republican to the House continuously since 1991. That 35-year run ended when independent Brent Johnson, a former borough assembly member, unseated incumbent Sarah Vance by about 60 votes.

It was Johnson’s second try; he challenged Vance in 2024 after she voted against overriding Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s veto of a school-funding increase and lost by nearly 500 votes. This time, he said, three issues moved voters: school closures weighing on communities, frustration over setnetting closures on the east side of Cook Inlet, and the national mood.

“President Trump — the world is finally seeing him for what he is, which is a conman and a cheat and a fake,” Johnson told Alaska Public Media. “So I think all of those things affected the vote.”

Johnson plans to join the Democratic coalition. The other three House flips: independent Joy Beth Cottle beat Republican Harmony Tomaszewski in the Fairbanks area; Democrat Denny Wells defeated Republican Mia Costello by eight points in Anchorage’s Sand Lake district; and Democrat Cliff Groh won an open seat with 64 percent in a north Anchorage district that includes Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson after Republican incumbent David Nelson declined to seek re-election.

The Matanuska-Susitna Borough produced the night’s closest margins and the only two come-from-behind wins. In the Big Lake district, Republican Rep. Kevin McCabe led former Alaska Wildlife Troopers director and union leader Doug Massie by more than 300 first-choice votes, but second-choice votes from Democrat Sandra Loomis’s supporters gave Massie a three-vote edge after ranked-choice tabulation.

McCabe told the Mat-Su Sentinel he will request a recount; the state covers the cost in races this tight.

Massie, who would join the all-Republican minority caucus if the count holds, said voters responded to his willingness to cross caucus lines.

“I might be the guy that gets admonished for voting outside of you know the minority lines, because if it’s right for Alaska, I’m going to vote that way. If it’s right for the people, I’m going to vote that way.”

Massie told Alaska Public Media. Two other Mat-Su races are also in recount territory: Ken McCarty leads Gina Wall by about two dozen votes for an Eagle River seat, and Sutton Republican Rep. Garret Nelson won re-election by just four votes after tabulation.

In the Senate, Wasilla Republican Sen. Cathy Tilton lost to fellow conservative Ryan Berry — another come-from-behind win, with second-choice votes from another Republican and a Democrat on the ballot pushing Berry ahead by more than 450 votes. No seats changed party control in the Senate, but the bipartisan majority shrank as three Republicans moved to the minority caucus, leaving a razor-thin 11–9 split that could complicate the majority’s agenda.