Frankel Jewish Academy 10th-Graders Explore Identity on Montana Trip

“Even though our cultures are very different, I noticed that both value remembering the past and making sure future generations stay connected to where they came from,” said Brynn Rebeck ’29, a sophomore at Frankel Jewish Academy.

That realization anchored the school’s fifth annual trip to Montana, a week that moved 10th-grade students from the geysers of Yellowstone to the Northern Cheyenne Reservation for five nights of camping and direct cultural exchange.

The program, run in partnership with The Lodge Approach, is designed to pull students out of their Metro Detroit routines and into a setting — and a community — where the questions of memory, identity and survival feel immediate rather than academic.

“We had gone there to watch, listen and learn,” said Marcus Mendleson, outreach & engagement coordinator at Frankel Jewish Academy, who led the trip. “Being invited to take part made the experience feel different.”

The invitation came during a powwow in Ashland, the first time an FJA group has attended one. Students and staff were asked to join a communal dance, a gesture Mendleson described as small but resonant.

Earlier in the week, the group visited a former Native American boarding school, a site that brought the history of forced assimilation into sharp focus and sparked conversations about what it takes to keep traditions alive.

Students heard stories about family, history and traditional plant uses. They saw tools and clothing, made frybread, and learned directly from Northern Cheyenne community members. For Orly Morganstein ’29, the simplest moments carried weight: sitting around a bonfire under a sky unpolluted by city lights, spotting the Big Dipper for the first time.

Those observations began to mirror the students’ own Jewish practice. Morning services were optional; one morning, boys put on tefillin with the mountains behind them. Friday night and Shabbat morning services were student-led, transplanting familiar liturgy into an unfamiliar setting. Shabbat itself became a structured pause, a designated time to process the week’s intensity.

“This experience has pushed me closer to my classmates, the way school wouldn’t usually do,” said Rachel Davidov ’29, who had been hesitant to step outside her social circle before the trip.

The shift was visible in the logistics of the week: students who rarely spoke to each other walked side by side on hikes, waited for one another on steeper trails, and collaborated on setting up tents. Long van rides became extended seminars on everything they had witnessed. By the time Mendleson led formal reflection sessions near the trip’s end, he found the most honest conversations had already happened organically.

Alumni consistently cite the Montana trip as a defining memory of their FJA years. Current seniors reference it unprompted during exit reflections. Mendleson said he now understands why — not only for the bison herd that slowed their drive through Yellowstone, or the stars over the reservation, but for the relationships forged in the space between observation and participation.

Frankel Jewish Academy opened in August 2000 with 51 ninth- and 10th-grade students in the lower level of the Jewish Community Center in West Bloomfield. It was the first multi-denominational Jewish high school in Michigan, created to continue Jewish education for graduates of Hillel Day School.

In 2002 the school received a $20 million endowment, then the largest ever for a Jewish high school, and was renamed for donors Jean and Samuel Frankel. By 2007 enrollment had grown to more than 220 students and the academy moved into a new 50,000-square-foot facility on the JCC’s third floor.

“Those are the parts I expect this group will still be talking about when they are seniors, too,” Mendleson said.