GOP Civil War Cuts ‘Gang of Eight’ to Three in 2024 Idaho Midterm

Idaho Republicans just finished a two-year civil war in the Magic Valley, and the moderates won back the territory they lost in 2024.

Voters in the November 3 midterm cut the self-styled “Gang of Eight” — hard-right lawmakers swept in by an out-of-state PAC — down to three surviving members, replacing five seats with legislators closer to the political center. The GOP still holds an 80 percent supermajority in both chambers, but the ideological center of gravity in Boise has shifted.

“We spent the last two years working really hard to make a change,” former Rep. Linda Wright Hartgen said. “And we made quite a change.”

“The Magic Valley has always been considered the steady Eddie of the state. They could be counted on to make good decisions. And all of a sudden, that was gone.”

Chenele Dixon, former state representative

The 2024 takeover cost Make Liberty Win, a Virginia-based PAC, less than $19,000 in the Magic Valley primaries. Mailers depicting incumbents as magicians hypnotizing children or paling around with Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer blindsided a region accustomed to retail politics — irrigation district meetings, county fair booths, and long conversations at the doorstep.

Shoshone falls on the snake river carving through a deep basalt canyon in magic valley twin

“Idaho is a cheap date,” Rep. Jack Nelsen, a retiring dairyman from Jerome, said. “For a few million dollars, you can get bills pushed onto a national stage that I don’t think any Idahoan on Main Street would agree with.”

Independent expenditures are rising because the return on investment is high: sparse populations, closed primaries, and cheap media markets let a few thousand dollars swing a legislative seat that controls a $12 billion agricultural economy.

The state party platform has ballooned from 20 pages to 36 in two years, now calling for nullifying federal authority inside Idaho, repealing the 17th Amendment, abolishing the Federal Reserve, and banning abortion without exception. At the June convention, Hartgen — a self-described “pro-life, pro-family” Republican — called the proceedings “bedlam.”

Gop civil war in south carolina republicans sink trump backed redistricting plan ahead of midterms

Party Chairwoman Dorothy Moon framed the fight in an op-ed titled “How to Identify a Real Republican,” warning against candidates who “echo left-wing talking points like ‘common sense background checks'” or “hide behind left-wing euphemisms like ‘women’s healthcare.'” Gang of Eight members labeled their primary challengers “products of the government class” seeking to protect themselves from “the people who came to limit it.”

“We can agree 80% of the time, and be good with that. We don’t have to agree 90%, 95%, 100% of the time. I don’t even know a single household that agrees 100% of the time, and that’s healthy.”

Cherie Vollmer, Twin Falls City Council member

Vollmer unseated Rep. David Leavitt by rejecting the fear-based mailers that worked in 2024. Newcomers from California told her the Magic Valley campaign felt tame by big-state standards. She leaned into longer conversations and educational events instead.

The Magic Valley spans eight counties across south-central Idaho — Blaine, Camas, Cassia, Gooding, Jerome, Lincoln, Minidoka, and Twin Falls — and held a combined population of 185,790 in 2010, about 12 percent of the state total.

Its name dates to the first decade of the 1900s, when Milner and Minidoka Dams and canal systems such as the Gooding Milner “magically” turned desert into some of the Northwest’s most productive farmland, spawning most of the region’s cities between 1900 and 1910.

Nelsen, who has stopped attending state GOP conventions he calls “radical,” put it bluntly: “I’ve been a Republican forever, but they’re making it really hard to be a Republican.”