Medina Judge Kept 1,700 Registration Blocks Despite New Ohio Law

Medina Municipal Court Judge Gary Werner kept nearly 1,700 vehicle registration blocks in place after an Ohio law took effect on April 9, 2025, that eliminated them for unpaid traffic fines, The Marshall Project reported.

The blocks prevent drivers from renewing license plates, exposing them to new tickets and fines if they keep driving. State Rep. Darnell Brewer, a Cleveland Democrat who co-sponsored the law, said Werner has disrespected the legislation and called on the Ohio Supreme Court to intervene. “It is wrong,” Brewer said. “They need to be removed. The Ohio Supreme Court should deal with this judge.”

House Bill 29 passed after a Marshall Project–Cleveland and News 5 investigation showed the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles issued nearly 200,000 new license suspensions in 2022 for debt-related reasons. From April 9 to May 9 last year, more than 500 courts across Ohio removed over 272,000 registration blocks and suspensions, state records show. Medina Municipal Court, which handles cases for Medina, Brunswick and 13 villages and townships in northern Medina County, did not follow suit.

Attorneys with the Legal Aid Society of Cleveland and an advisory written for the Ohio Judicial Conference by a retired judge said the law also erased past registration blocks for unpaid fines and court costs.

But Clerk of Court Mike Kovac said a BMV employee told his office that blocks attached before the effective date were not subject to the new law. “We certainly want to be abiding by the law but, as so often happens with these changes, clear direction can often be difficult to come by,” Kovac wrote in an email.

Medina Judge Kept 1,700 Registration Blocks Despite New Ohio Law
Photo: happeningnow.news

The blocks arrived just before the deadline

Records show the court added nearly 950 registration blocks in the weeks between the bill’s passage and its effective date. In dozens of cases, the block was filed the same day the case was sent to a collection agency.

Andy Mascio told The Marshall Project that a court employee said the judge interpreted the law to mean everything enacted before April 9, 2025, was still active. A docket review of Mascio’s wife’s case shows the court added a registration block on April 8, 2025 — the day before the law took effect — and sent the case to collections.

“They are always right and won’t even look at documents or have a discussion,” Mascio wrote on a Medina community Facebook page. “I was told the only way to do this is hire a lawyer and file a case. WTF is wrong with people? I should be able to speak to someone to bring this to someone’s attention.”

Commenters on the post described similar frustrations spanning 19 months. Brandon Sterrick, who has a paralyzed left arm, said he accumulated an estimated seven to 10 registration blocks during a difficult period years ago and could not get answers from the court about why they hadn’t been lifted.

He said he and his mother encountered hostility from a staffer when they requested a hearing. “They treat everybody like criminals,” Sterrick said. “I don’t understand this.”

Donna Bartolozzi, Sterrick’s mother, said she witnessed a staff member ridicule her son over his disability. She said the blocks have also cost her money because she financed her son’s car to keep it in her name. “As a taxpayer and voter, I’m watching people get ripped off because the court is trying to interpret the law at its own discretion,” she said.

Kovac said he was surprised to learn of the frustrations and that he takes “customer service very seriously here.” He encouraged people to contact him with complaints. Werner, who has presided over the court since 2017, did not respond to repeated emails, calls and courthouse visits from The Marshall Project – Cleveland.

Werner was born in Cleveland and graduated from Brunswick High School in 1979. He earned a B.A. in economics, summa cum laude, from UCLA and a J.D. from Loyola Law School in Los Angeles. Before taking the bench, he practiced law for approximately 23 years and was licensed in both California and Ohio.

He previously served as mayor of Brunswick from 2010 to 2013 and on its city council from 2004 to 2009. In December 2021, he secured Ohio Supreme Court certification to operate the county’s only Veterans Treatment Court, known as Valor Court.

The question now is whether the Ohio Supreme Court will act on Brewer’s demand or if drivers will be forced into individual lawsuits to clear blocks the law was designed to eliminate.