Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Johnson Eliminated From ‘Dancing With the Stars’ Semifinals Despite Perfect 60

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated from Dancing With the Stars on Tuesday night despite topping the leaderboard with a cumulative 60 out of 60.

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated from Dancing With the Stars on Tuesday night, a stunner that sent the season’s only two-time perfect-score couple home one week shy of the finale.

The semifinal episode, broadcast live on ABC and Disney+ on November 17, required the six remaining couples to perform two routines each — one ballroom, one Latin — with the combined judges’ scores and viewer votes determining the final five.

Shum and Johnson topped the leaderboard with a cumulative 60 out of 60, matching Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov point for point, yet the public vote dropped the actor-choreographer duo from the competition.

Carrie Ann Inaba was visibly stunned when co-hosts Alfonso Ribeiro and Julianne Hough announced the result. “I feel like Dancing With the Stars is synonymous with Glee,” Shum said after his final quickstep to the Naya Rivera version of “Valerie,” a deliberate homage to his late former castmate. “We miss you, baby girl.”

The scoreboard that didn’t save them

Shum and Johnson opened the night with a paso doble to Rihanna’s “We Found Love” — 30/30 — and closed it with the quickstep that earned a second perfect 30. Glenn and Pashkov mirrored the feat with a salsa to Celia Cruz’s “Bemba Colorá” and a Viennese waltz to Ariana Grande’s “Dangerous Woman.”

Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas posted a 30 and a 29; Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach turned a 27 into a 30 with a jive to “Footloose”; Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik moved from 27 to 28; and Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold held steady at 24 both rounds.

Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Johnson Eliminated From 'Dancing With the Stars' Semifinals Despite Perfect 60
Photo: E! News
Couple Round 1 Round 2 Total
Amber Glenn & Pasha Pashkov 30 (Salsa) 30 (Viennese Waltz) 60
Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson 30 (Paso Doble) 30 (Quickstep) 60
Ezra Frech & Daniella Karagach 27 (Quickstep) 30 (Jive) 57
Connor Wood & Rylee Arnold 24 (Jive) 24 (Quickstep) 48

The arithmetic is brutal: Wood and Arnold finished 12 points behind the leaders yet survive, while Shum and Johnson exit with the night’s only flawless card.

Live coast-to-coast finale, new voting window

Ribeiro used the results show to announce a scheduling first: the three-hour Season 35 finale will air live at 8 p.m. ET / 5 p.m. PT next Tuesday, allowing West Coast viewers to vote in real time rather than during the traditional East Coast–only window. Voting typically closes roughly 45 minutes after the final performance; the simulcast effectively adds three hours of eligibility for Pacific Time audiences.

The finale format expands to three rounds per couple — a judges’ choice, an instant dance, and a freestyle — with all eliminated celebrities returning for a final group number. Dewan, Guillermo Rodriguez, Julia Stiles, Tyler Cameron, and others are confirmed for the reunion.

Harry Shum Jr., Jenna Johnson Eliminated From 'Dancing With the Stars' Semifinals Despite Perfect 60
Photo: TODAY

What the paychecks actually look like

Elimination also stops the weekly paycheck escalator. Variety reported in 2019 that contestants start at $125,000 for rehearsals and the first two shows, with incremental raises each week they survive. Bobby Bones, the Season 27 winner, told Jason Tartick’s Trading Secrets podcast in September 2025 that his actual earnings reached nearly $400,000 — well above the $295,000 cap cited in the earlier report. ABC has not publicly confirmed any of these figures.

“That show pays OK,” the radio personality said on a Sept. 2025 episode of Jason Tartick’s podcast Trading Secrets. “Like, first episode, no money. Second episode, $10,000. I think it’s like, $10,000, $10,000, $20,000, $20,000. It ends up being $50,000 an episode if you last.”

— Bobby Bones, Season 27 champion, on Trading Secrets (Sept. 2025)

Shum and Johnson’s exit freezes their earnings at the semifinal tier; the five remaining couples — Glenn, Higgins, Frech, Ali, and Wood — will each bank at least one more weekly increment before the mirrorball is awarded.

“That wasn’t good, that was impeccable on every level — style, execution, performance. The sync was out of this world,” Bruno told Shum after the quickstep. The judges’ consensus was unanimous; the audience disagreed.