NBC Projects Peltola Beats Sullivan in Alaska; AP Says Dems Reach 56 Senate Seats

Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, NBC News projects, flipping the last undecided Senate seat in the country and expanding the Democratic majority to 56 seats.

The call came Tuesday night after Peltola crossed the 50% threshold in first-choice votes, avoiding the ranked-choice tabulation that Alaska’s election system triggers when no candidate clears a majority. With just over 285,000 ballots counted as of Monday, Peltola stood at 49.98% to Sullivan’s 45.93%, The Seattle Times reported. The remaining votes — including those for a second candidate named Dan J. Sullivan and perennial candidate Gerald Heikes — were not enough to force a runoff.

“As a lifelong Alaskan who has dedicated my career to serving our state, there is no greater honor than having Alaskans’ support in our fight to take on corporate greed, lower costs, and put Alaska first,” Peltola wrote on X Tuesday night. “Thank you, Alaska. Let’s get to work.”

The ballot-stacking storm

The race’s final weeks were consumed by allegations that Peltola’s campaign helped recruit Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher with no party affiliation, to siphon votes from the incumbent.

The New York Times first reported the accusation less than a week before the November 3 election, citing text messages and interviews with Peltola’s former campaign manager, who was fired shortly before the primary and later sought to recant her statements, according to the Associated Press.

Mary Peltola 55 votes away from 50% threshold in Alaska Senate race against Dan Sullivan — The Hill

President Donald Trump, who endorsed Sullivan, seized on the report. He posted a clip of commentator Bill O’Reilly claiming baselessly that the “Democratic Party in Alaska cheated” and called for Peltola’s prosecution.

The Justice Department filed a lawsuit — which Trump said he ordered — seeking to block certification if Sullivan lost, arguing voter confusion over the two Sullivans. A federal judge dismissed the suit the weekend before Election Day, though the Justice Department appealed. Peltola called the lawsuit “flagrant corruption.”

Both Peltola and Dan J. Sullivan denied any coordination. “I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent,” Peltola told supporters in Juneau days before the election, the AP reported. Dan J. Sullivan has also said he made his own decision to run and has not responded to AP messages since the Times article published.

Us news alaskasenate filepic get
Photo: courant.com

A red state rewritten

Alaska has not voted for a Democrat for president since 1964 — before either Sullivan, 61, or Peltola, 53, were born — and its other Senate seat has been held by the Republican Murkowski dynasty since 1981, NBC News noted.

Yet Peltola had already won statewide twice: a 2022 special election for the at-large House seat and a full term later that year, becoming the first Alaska Native in Congress. She lost that seat to Republican Nick Begich in 2024 but out-raised Sullivan nearly three-to-one this cycle — $37 million to $14 million through mid-October, per NBC News.

Democrats flipped nine Senate seats in this year’s midterms, the most since 1958, turning a 53-47 Republican majority into a 56-44 Democratic advantage, the AP reported. The new caucus includes independents Angus King of Maine and Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Alaska also elected a Democrat as governor for the first time since 1998: former state lawmaker Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins won with 50.9% of first-choice votes, defeating three Republicans including a Trump-endorsed candidate.

His leading opponent, Bernadette Wilson, conceded Monday. “His story and mine will forever be intricately tied to each other,” Wilson said in a video. “He will be just the third governor of Alaska who was born and raised in our great state.”

What remains unsettled

Sullivan has not conceded. His spokesperson Nate Adams said Monday the campaign would “let that process run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified,” which is not expected until November 25.

The U.S. House race also remains uncalled: Republican incumbent Nick Begich led independent Bill Hill 47.7% to 41.7% as of Monday, with a ranked-choice tabulation set for Wednesday. Incarcerated Democratic candidate Eric Hafner received 7.8% despite Hill allies urging Democrats to back Hill.

Around a dozen legislative races are also headed to ranked-choice tabulation Wednesday, with final certification weeks away.