Hawaii Republican Assembly President Sues to Strike Down Hawaiian Home Lands Blood-Quantum Rule

A federal lawsuit filed this month by Eric Ryan, president of the Hawaii Republican Assembly, is asking a court to strike down the blood-quantum requirement that governs who can lease Hawaiian Home Lands, Honolulu Civil Beat reported.

The complaint, lodged October 23, argues that the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act’s 50-percent ancestry threshold violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal-protection clause and the Fifth Amendment’s due-process protections. Ryan is represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a national public-interest law firm that has challenged race-conscious policies across the country.

The trust at the center of the case

Congress passed the HHCA in 1921, setting aside roughly 200,000 acres to rehabilitate a Native Hawaiian population that had been devastated by disease, land loss, and the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom. The Admission Act of 1959 required Hawaii to adopt the HHCA into its state constitution and barred amendments to beneficiary qualifications without federal consent — a binding federal-state compact that Civil Beat notes is distinct from an ordinary state housing preference.

The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands currently manages a waitlist of nearly 30,000 applicants, a figure Civil Beat cited from the department’s own reporting. A Puʻuhonua subdivision home under construction in Wailuku was photographed December 6, 2025, illustrating the ongoing but slow pace of lease awards.

Political classification versus racial classification

The legal fight hinges on whether the ancestry rule is a racial preference subject to strict scrutiny or a political classification rooted in the federal trust relationship. In Morton v. Mancari (1974), the U.S. Supreme Court upheld hiring preferences for members of federally recognized tribes as political, not racial.

In Rice v. Cayetano (2000), the Court struck down ancestry-based voting in Office of Hawaiian Affairs elections under the Fifteenth Amendment but explicitly declined to decide whether Mancari applies to Native Hawaiians.

Ryan’s amended complaint seeks to extend Rice’s reasoning to the HHCA itself, asking a court to apply strict scrutiny to the 50-percent blood-quantum rule. Civil Beat reported that the plaintiff invokes the Fourteenth Amendment against the state and the Fifth Amendment’s equal-protection component against the federal government.

On January 16, 2025, the Department of the Interior issued Solicitor’s Opinion M-37083, analyzing federal trust responsibilities toward Native Hawaiians and Hawaiian Home Lands. The opinion was suspended for review on February 28, 2025, and remains a record of legal analysis rather than operative guidance, according to Civil Beat. Ryan’s filing nevertheless treats the trust framework as a racial classification vulnerable to constitutional challenge.

Ripple risks for other Hawaiian institutions

The complaint does not directly challenge Kamehameha Schools, the private charitable trust established by the will of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, which gives admissions preference to students of Hawaiian ancestry. But Civil Beat warned that the constitutional reasoning advanced against the HHCA could be deployed against other ancestry-based protections if courts accept the argument that such classifications are inherently racial.

Traditional and customary rights — including water use for kalo cultivation and gathering — are protected under Article XII, Section 7 of the Hawaii Constitution and the public-trust duties in Article XI, Sections 1 and 7. The Waiāhole Ditch decisions affirmed those duties. Civil Beat cautioned that arguments undermining the HHCA’s trust foundation could eventually threaten those independent constitutional and public-trust protections.

History of the 50-percent threshold

Prince Jonah Kūhiō Kalanianaʻole, the territorial delegate who shepherded the HHCA through Congress, originally advocated a 1/32 blood-quantum threshold to include as many beneficiaries as possible. The 50-percent requirement emerged from political compromises with sugar and ranching interests tied to the plantation oligarchy that participated in the 1893 overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom, Civil Beat reported.

“We cannot allow external legal challenges to exploit internal debates over eligibility to dismantle the trust itself,” the Civil Beat commentary said. “Those seeking reform and those defending the trust share the same objective: preserving Kūhiō’s legacy of rehabilitating our people on ancestral land.”

Pacific Legal Foundation, founded in Sacramento in 1973, is the oldest libertarian public-interest law firm in the United States. Its attorneys work pro bono and have won 18 cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, most recently Sheetz v. County of El Dorado. The organization operates with a staff of over 100 from offices in Sacramento, Arlington, Virginia, and Palm Beach Gardens, Florida, and accepts no government funding.

Case proceeds in federal court

The case, Ryan v. Watson, proceeds in federal court. The state and federal defendants have not yet filed responses in the public docket. The court will have to decide whether the HHCA’s eligibility criteria are inseparable from the federal trust compact enacted in 1921 and entrenched in the 1959 Admission Act — or whether they are, as the plaintiff contends, a racial classification that cannot survive strict scrutiny.