Hundreds of Ballots From Tougaloo, JSU Students Rejected in U.S. Senate Race

Hundreds of provisional ballots cast by students at Tougaloo College and Jackson State University were rejected in Mississippi’s recent Senate election, leaving many first-time voters feeling disenfranchised despite Democrat Scott Colom’s historic victory over incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith.

The confusion stemmed from a geographic quirk few students knew existed: Tougaloo’s campus straddles the Hinds–Madison county line, with dormitories in Madison County and academic buildings in Hinds County, Capital B reported. Students who registered using campus addresses but listed the wrong county saw their affidavit ballots tossed, as did some who presented valid student IDs — identification the Southern Coalition for Social Justice says is legal under state law.

“We’re like, oh shoot, we are actually making a difference,” Muarib Abdul-Tawwab, an 18-year-old Tougaloo freshman who helped register at least 70 peers in October, told Capital B, recalling election-night excitement as returns tightened. That energy curdled when provisional ballots began piling up uncounted. In Hinds County alone, officials received 2,426 affidavit ballots and rejected more than half, a Resolution Board member told Mississippi Public Broadcasting Online.

Hundreds of Ballots From Tougaloo, JSU Students Rejected in U.S. Senate Race
Photo: yahoo.com

“It is appalling the number of issues that we’ve seen, and we had on Election Day, and now we’re seeing the extension of that post-Election Day in a way that is not great,” said Lydia Grizzell, policy and advocacy manager at the ACLU of Mississippi, speaking to Capital B. She pointed to Mississippi’s lack of online voter registration, strict voter-ID rules, and inoperable machines as drivers of the weeklong counting delay, noting that counting procedures varied by county — some conducted behind closed doors.

“Students who want to register have to write everything by hand, so when we think about that, we think about how things are spelled correctly,” Aznii Welchlin, Tougaloo’s student government association president, said. The 21-year-old senior from West Jackson said she never knew the campus spanned two counties until this cycle — and neither did alumni mentors who attended Tougaloo during the Civil Rights Movement.

Welchlin tied the administrative tangle to a broader pattern: the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision this year gutting sections of the Voting Rights Act, which she said opened the door for Republican-led redistricting ahead of the midterms. “I wasn’t shocked that a small detail led to tossing out hundreds of Black students’ votes,” she said. “I’ve seen how politicians have used tricks to stop Black and marginalized groups from voting.”

Mississippi still counting votes in Senate race, many students' ballots tossed out — WTHR

Abdul-Tawwab framed the stakes in material terms. “Across the state, anywhere Black people live, schools are underfunded, and there are too many food deserts,” he told Capital B. His pitch to out-of-state classmates: “If you don’t think your vote matters, it does matter. But I say your vote matters more in Mississippi than it does where you’re from. … Where you’re from probably has a better, healthier voting practice than Mississippi does.”

Colom’s win makes him Mississippi’s first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction. He delivered his victory speech at Tougaloo on Nov. 11, a gesture Welchlin said “warmed her heart” after many students’ first voting experience ended in discouragement. “They were really excited that they got to vote or tried to vote, and because of that, we’re going to get them re-registered,” she said.

Jackson State University, founded as Natchez Seminary on October 23, 1877, became a state-supported public institution in 1940 and took its current name in 1974. The campus still bears bullet marks from the May 14, 1970, police shooting that killed two students and injured 12 during a protest. Today the university enrolls approximately 6,500 undergraduate and graduate students and is classified among R2 doctoral universities with high research activity.

Welchlin is now working with the Mississippi Access Project, a student-led coalition founded by Jackson State activist Jakari Holland, to push for online registration and same-day registration before the next cycle. The immediate test comes Dec. 1, when Mississippians return to the polls for runoffs in state House Districts 70 and 77 and a special general runoff for the 7th Circuit Court district attorney in Hinds County.