Idaho Ranks 8th in Religious Liberty Index; Senator Urges Further Protections

In a column for the Coeur d’Alene Press, Idaho State Sen. Ben Toews argues the state should pursue additional religious liberty protections after rising to 8th nationally in a new index.

  • Idaho ranked 8th in the 2026 Religious Liberty in the States Index, up from 13th last year.
  • The index, released this summer by First Liberty Institute, reviewed 50 safeguards across all states.
  • Toews cites the Medical Ethics Defense Act as a key factor in the improved ranking.
  • He identifies gaps in protections for wedding vendors, clergy, public officials, and houses of worship during emergencies.

Index ranks Idaho 8th after legislative gains

Idaho moved up five spots in the 2026 Religious Liberty in the States Index released this summer by First Liberty Institute’s Center for Religion, Culture & Democracy, Coeur d’Alene Press reported. The index evaluated 50 constitutional and statutory safeguards across all 50 states. Toews writes that the gains follow legislation such as the Medical Ethics Defense Act, which protects the conscience rights of medical professionals.

Gaps remain in wedding, clergy and emergency protections

Toews notes that nearly 14,000 weddings took place in Idaho in 2025 with over $425 million spent on ceremonies, yet faith-based businesses providing goods or services for marriages lack state-level protections when requests conflict with religious beliefs. While the U.S. Supreme Court’s rulings in Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018) and 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis (2023) offer some First Amendment protections, Toews argues a state law shielding bakers, photographers, florists and other creative professionals could prevent years of litigation. Mississippi and Arkansas have enacted such laws, according to the column.

Idaho has also not passed “Pastor Protection Acts” that protect clergy, churches and religious organizations from being forced to participate in marriage ceremonies that violate their beliefs. Arkansas, ranked first in the index, has such a law. The state has not protected public officials who object to solemnizing marriages on religious or personal grounds, a measure Mississippi has adopted.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, several states barred religious gatherings while allowing establishments such as liquor stores, marijuana dispensaries and bicycle repair shops to operate as essential. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled emergency orders could not single out religious institutions for harsher restrictions than comparable secular establishments. Eighteen states, including Utah, have since codified statutes prohibiting governments from treating houses of worship differently than similarly situated businesses. Idaho is not among them.

“Many of the 50 safeguards measured in the index are currently in place for our state which ensures the people of Idaho can exercise their faith freely both in public and private without compromise,” Toews writes. “But there is more to be done, and it is incumbent on the lawmakers across the state to work diligently to protect those rights and to pass laws to ensure protections are upheld.”