Indiana Courts Issue Separate Rulings on Insurance Deadline, Property Tax

Two distinct legal battles tested state property and insurance rules on Monday, highlighting how strict filing deadlines and valuation formulas shape outcomes across Indiana courts.

The Indiana Court of Appeals issued a ruling in Mark A. Traino, et al. v. Kyle Knutson, affirming a lower court decision that barred an insurance procurement lawsuit over timing rules, The Indiana Lawyer reported.

Special Judge Michael A. Fish previously granted summary judgment in favor of Kyle Knutson, individually and doing business as Valparaiso First Insurance, Inc., concluding that Mark A. Traino and other plaintiffs missed the two-year statutory window.

According to the appellate panel, the cause of action accrued when the policyholders should have known about a lack of coverage for their vehicle, which the court determined was when the insurance policy was first issued.

Judge Pyle authored the opinion for the court, with Judges May and Scheele concurring to lock in the precedent regarding negligent procurement claims.

Jason R. Moseley, Miguel F. Martinez, and James A. Hoffman of the Law Office of Moseley & Martinez LLC in Merrillville represented the appellants during the proceedings.

Indiana supreme court affirms trust order in life

Richard A. Rocap of the Rocap Law Firm LLC in Indianapolis represented the appellee, defending the timeline defense that ultimately closed the courthouse doors.

Meanwhile, the Indiana Tax Court tackled a separate property valuation dispute in Echo Park Perry, LLC v. Echo Park Perry, LLC v. Hendricks County Assessor, revolving around a multi-family rental apartment complex in Plainfield.

The Hendricks County Assessor placed an assessment value on the apartment complex that Echo Park contested, prompting an administrative challenge before the Indiana Board of Tax Review.

The Board resolved that dispute by applying Indiana Code § 6-1.1-4-39(a), a statute mandating that true tax value be derived from the lowest valuation among three specific appraisal methods.

Echo Park argued on appeal that the statute compelled the Board to minimize valuations by selecting the absolute lowest figures presented across all evidence.

Judge McAdam wrote that the statute contains no such mandate requiring the state board to systematically minimize valuations or disregard probative evidence supporting higher estimates.

The Tax Court affirmed that the Board acted properly within its discretion by selecting the lowest credible valuation based on evidence from one expert while rejecting alternative figures.

Bradley D. Hasler and Jeffrey T. Bennett of Dentons Bingham Greenebaum LLP in Indianapolis argued the case on behalf of petitioner Echo Park Perry, LLC.

Ayn K. Engle of Indianapolis represented the respondent county assessor, securing a lawful determination that left the local property tax assessment intact.